ASHLAG ARCHIVE
EnglishעבריתРусскийEspañol
← Back to Library

The Writings of Baal HaSulam / Articles / The History of the Interference of Philosophy in Religion

Baal HaSulam
Text size

The Writings of Baal HaSulam / Articles / The History of the Interference of Philosophy in Religion

6. How did philosophy become mixed with religion? The beginning of this matter must be attributed to the faith of the Ishmaelites. After Mohammedanism (Islam) peeled the outer skin from Judaism, it found itself very weak in holding its ground against Judaism, from which it was born, as well as against Christianity, its older neighbor. Added to their great trouble was the philosophical spirit that was multiplying and spreading among them. They went and gathered a large camp of philosophical scholars in order to adapt their religion to the spirit of philosophy, and from then on, their religion took a philosophical direction. Taking into account the cultural dominance they possessed at that time, they indeed succeeded in achieving great expansion throughout all the countries of the East. In response to Mohammedanism, Christianity also became envious, and they drew as many philosophical ideas to themselves as they could. They fortified their religion with logical concepts in addition to prophetic ones, kneading them into a single, spiced dough, so they would have the strength and ability to fight against philosophical Mohammedanism.

The Writings of Baal HaSulam / Articles / The Wisdom of the Torah vs. Philosophy – The Individual and His Freedom

9. The beginning of the matter occurred during the flourishing of the Ishmaelite kingdom at the end of the Geonic period. Due to its competition with Christianity, it gathered a large group of the philosophers of that time at the expense of the royal treasury, so they could establish their religion firmly upon logical, philosophical foundations. This continued for several generations until they managed to create a complete theology that truly astonished the intellectuals of that generation, to the point that the young Jewish intellectuals began to be drawn after it. Then the Great Eagle, the Rambam (Maimonides), of blessed memory, arose and went forth to save his people. He wrote his famous book, The Guide for the Perplexed, finding no other way to undermine this theology than to show how our Torah is founded upon philosophical logic, while the Ishmaelite theology was founded on falsehood, boasting that it was based on logic. He demonstrated there the truth of philosophy (and this is evident to anyone who has seen that book). Therefore, he refers to those scholars who created this as the sect of the "Mutakallimun" [Speakers], meaning words without reason or taste.

10. The Books of the Rambam However, the Rambam did not worry about future generations, for he knew he was unique, and he relied on the other sages of his generation to know how to guard the truth of the Torah and not allow his ideas to spread among the public. And indeed, this was so in his generation. But the Satan came and caused confusion in the generations that followed, and his ideas spread widely—because at that time, Christianity also created a grand theology for themselves, and intellectuals increasingly mixed the Rambam’s philosophical concepts and spread them among the people in order to assimilate with the gentiles. Then, the sages gathered and burned the books of the Rambam himself due to their corrupting influence, even though they knew the Rambam’s intention was for the good. To save the public from that foreign mixture, they decreed a strict prohibition at that time against all study of philosophy, as is known.

11. The Spread of Theology in Christianity and Judaism Nevertheless, as days multiplied and the power of the sages weakened—especially in the Western countries where the nations opened the gates of their wisdom to the Jews, and they mingled with the gentiles and learned their ways—the theology spread first among the intellectuals and then, knowingly and unknowingly, was brought into the broader public. This crystallized to such an extent that no one could distinguish any difference between this theology and our received Torah, except regarding the matter of graven images and masks, of course. In truth, several complete books were composed in Israel that, from beginning to end, are taken from the words of Christian theology [Note: And from there emerged the Reform movement, which dared to uproot words of Torah in places they desired, according to the spirit of theology], except that they took from there and replaced the ideas of graven images with the ideas of the negation of form. Regarding this, the scripture laments (Proverbs 30:22-23), "Under a slave when he becomes king... and a maidservant when she inherits her mistress." And this is the entire sorrowful history that has confused all the modern scholars, from the least to the greatest, who seem to me like children held captive among idolaters, to the point that they are incapable of even conceiving that all this theology is not considered part of our Torah. On the contrary, they sit and grieve over why our literature is so poor in the spirit of theology.

The Writings of Baal HaSulam / Article: What is the Wisdom of Kabbalah

5. However, as stated, the matter of the wisdom of Kabbalah was under a strict obligation and necessity to be hidden entirely in those days. Because aside from the customary reason in those generations to hide all wisdom from the eyes of the masses (even external wisdom), added to this was that Christianity then began to spread. In its beginning, it had some foundations from this wisdom that they had stolen from our study halls; however, due to their ignorance, it was forgotten by them. Therefore, they would pursue the sages with all kinds of cunning to learn this wisdom from them. For this reason, they added seal upon seal to the wisdom until the Zohar was completely hidden, and was only found in the hands of the heads of the generations who led the Yeshivas. Thus, we also find the names of the Savoraic rabbis in the Zohar, because each one added to the previous ones, just as we find in the Mishna and Talmud. Logic dictates that the Savoraic rabbis greatly expanded the books of the Zohar beyond what the students of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai (Rashbi) arranged, because they did not seal it as they did the Mishna. This was because there was no fear of ignorant people accessing it, since it was hidden solely in the hands of the most trusted heads of the generation.

The Writings of Baal HaSulam / Articles / The History of the Wisdom of Kabbalah, its Concealment and Revelation / More on the History of the Wisdom

1. The Dispute Over the Oral Torah They concealed the study of Kabbalah for two reasons: First, because external wisdoms multiplied close to the Destruction [of the Temple], and the nature of wisdom is that it makes a person arrogant and expansive, developing the sense that all people's bodies are one, allowing one to evaluate and criticize his fellow. Therefore, men of faith concluded that human nature would not want to believe anything it could not comprehend on its own, except through absolute, tangible, physical obligation. And because the Sages hid the Oral Torah, the arrogant multiplied and denied it completely.

Kabbalah Did Not Develop Therefore, when they saw the unruliness of the world, they said it was better... to the masses and reveal the Oral Torah to them as something written, so they would not envy the Sages and would not rebel against the Torah and Mitzvot, for there is no greater jealousy than that of a hidden thing.

They Only Revealed the Wisdom to One in a Generation, the Av Beit Din The second reason is that Christianity began to spread, and because they wanted to increase their followers, they abolished the practical commandments of the Torah. However, they were left with nothing, and they would search the Midrashim for the inner meaning of the Torah so they could establish an intellectual, scientific religion. Therefore, the Sages gathered and concealed it completely, even though it was worthy, as they said (Chagigah 13a): "We do not reveal [the secrets] except to the Av Beit Din (Head of the Rabbinical Court)," and it is known that there was no more than one in a generation, as taught in Mishnah Avot.