Letters — Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein
Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Letters
Letter 9: The Reason for the Fear of Studying Kabbalah
B"H, 12th of Sivan, 5722 (1962), Tel Aviv
Joy of days and years of life to our Teacher, Rabbi David Stan, Shlita.
I received your letter from Friday, Erev Shabbat Parashat Bamidbar.
It has become clear to me that it is impossible to obtain the volumes of Talmud Eser Sefirot (TES) parts 5, 6, and 7; only from part 8 and onwards are available. I do not know what to do, for usually, a student must learn according to the order of the lessons. If so, why would you need the later lessons [without the earlier ones]? The money remains with me until you inform me what to do.
Regarding your question about what is written in the books, that one should not study the Wisdom of Kabbalah except "man from the mouth of man"[1]:
The main fear was always due to unworthy people who study Torah Shelo Lishma (not for its own sake), whose Torah becomes a Potion of Death for them. They might come to use Practical Kabbalah (Kabbalah Ma'asit) and incantations.
Furthermore, there is a fear of Corporealization (Hagshama - understanding spiritual concepts as physical).
However, our Rabbi, the Ari Ashlag (Baal HaSulam) zt"l, composed his books in such a way that these two fears do not exist.
Therefore, anyone whose heart is concerned within him and who wishes that his few years should not pass in vanity and emptiness, has no other choice but to engage in the Wisdom of Kabbalah and the Zohar.
The answer that Rabbi Akiva gave to Pappus ben Yehuda is well known: "If in the place of our vitality [the water/Torah] we are afraid, how much more so [on dry land]..." (Berachot 61b)[2].
Therefore, be strong and courageous, and God will be your help. Spend much time in the Yeshiva and ask for mercy, and "he who walks in integrity walks securely."
One who signs with the blessing of the Torah,
Yehuda Tzvi
I was very brief due to my many burdens, for praise God, I have finished all the Eight Gates (Shemona Shearim), and I have begun to explain Part Two of my commentary on the Tikunim. My prayer to God is that I may merit to finish the entire commentary, with God's help.
[1] See Ramban's Intro to Torah: "I faithfully inform... my words cannot be known by any intellect... except from the mouth of a Kabbalist sage to the ear of an understanding recipient." Also R' Chaim Vital, Intro to Shaar HaHakdamot.
[2] Referring to the Parable of the Fox and the Fishes: The fox suggests the fish come onto dry land to avoid the nets. The fish reply: "If we are afraid in the water, which is our life source, how much more so on land where we will surely die!" So too with Jews and the Torah.