Letters — Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein
Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Letters
Letter 13: Clarification of the Words of TES (Talmud Eser Sefirot)
B"H, Motzaei Shabbat Kodesh, Parashat Vayechi, 5726 (1966)
To the Honor of the Gaon, Rabbi A.L. Friedman, may the Lord protect him.[1]
I have looked into the question regarding Talmud Eser Sefirot Part 5, Item 47.
At first glance, it is true that there is a great contradiction:
In the paragraph starting "And now we shall explain," it is written in the middle: "And afterwards, the Vessel of Keter purifies and turns its face downward, meaning it purifies to Bechina Aleph (Level 1) and gives these three lights to the Vessel of Chochmah, etc."
However, in the paragraph starting "And one should not ask," it is written: "For the Vessel of Keter bestowed the ZON (Zeir Anpin and Nukva) to the Vessel of Chochmah as an illumination before it purified to Bechina Aleph."[2]
The Explanation is as follows:
In the paragraph "And now we shall explain," he does not descend to explain the specific details of the order of the first emanation. His intention there is only to explain the fixed principle of "Mati v'Lo Mati" (Reaching and Not Reaching):
When it is "Mati" (Reaching/Shining) in Keter, it reaches in VAK (Six Extremities) because of the Keter's rule not to shine downwards.
And when it is "Lo Mati" (Not Reaching) in Keter—because its Bechina Gimel (Level 3) and Bechina Bet (Level 2) have purified—the power of Keter's control ceases, and therefore it is "Mati" in GAR (First Three), which are ChaBaCh (Chochmah, Binah, Chesed)—three lights in the Vessel of Chochmah.
However, in the paragraph "And one should not ask," he explains in detail the order of the First Emanation of the Partzuf SAG.
There, it is clear that at the time of "Mati" in Keter, it illuminates the ZON to the Vessel of Chochmah as an illumination before it purifies to Bechina Aleph. This is because the Male and Female within the Vessel of Keter mate and give birth to a Male and Female similar to themselves.
This happens specifically before their purification to Bechina Aleph, because Bechina Aleph is Chesed, which is always Male and the son of Binah.
One must deepen this understanding even more, for this entire Partzuf is the secret of Abba and Imma and Yishsut dividing into four Partzufim to give birth to Chesed (which is Zeir Anpin). And it is known that every Upper One that is aroused to birth a level lower than itself, arouses within itself the aspect of the Lower One that is included in it, because... (Continuation missing)
[1] Rabbi Avraham Leib Friedman, a prominent student of Baal HaSulam.
[2] The contradiction: Does Keter give light to Chochmah only after purification (quote 1) or before purification (quote 2)?