ASHLAG ARCHIVE
EnglishעבריתРусскийEspañol

Article 4: Religion and Nation

Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein

Supplied text and translations. Original source files are available below; French translations are retained in the original downloads.

Source files
Text size

Articles & study materials — Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein

Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Articles

Article 4: Religion and Nation

The Essence of Religion

I have already explained the essence of Religion and the desired general form of the Service of God in several places, and I will repeat it here briefly.

The sole purpose of Religion is to bring man to the Love of Others (Ahavat HaZulat).

Through the performance of Torah and Mitzvot Lishma (for their own sake), a person elevates himself from his selfish lowliness and merits to become a Chariot (Merkava) for the Holy One, Blessed be He. This is the hoped-for perfection called "Adhesion" (Dvekut).

Since this word has become common in the mouths of the masses, it has lost almost all its content. However, if we properly value and visualize the Godly matter, and the minute value of the lowly created being, we will understand the great wonder in the word "Adhesion":

One who lives without it and then merits it is like a limb that was severed from the living body and became a dead limb; then, an expert physician came with good medicines and reconnected it to the body. Through this, all the life-force of the body shines into this limb as well. So too, the Godly part of the person who merits to adhere to his Root merits that the entire Root shines within him[1].

Thus, it will be understood how the single commandment "Love your neighbor as yourself" (Leviticus 19:18) includes all the commandments—both those between man and God and those between man and his fellow. For they are all directed toward one thing: to bring man to the final goal, which is Adhesion and Knowledge of God.

Even from a practical perspective, these two parts are actually one. When a person performs his deeds Lishma, without a mixture of self-love and self-benefit, he feels no difference in his actions whether he does them for the love of his friend or for the love of the Omnipresent.

Indeed, it is human nature that anything outside one's own body seems empty and unreal. But upon reaching—through great toil—the performance of Mitzvot Lishma, one exits and separates from the bosom of natural creation and elevates slowly, until he acquires a second nature of Love of Others and merits reaching the final goal, which is Adhesion.

However, by the term "Egoism" (Anochiut), I do not mean the measure of self-love imprinted in every creature, which is a necessary condition for its existence (without which it would not be a separate entity at all). Rather, egoism must not completely contradict the attribute of Love of Others.

It is proper to set strong boundaries for egoism: it should be preserved only to ensure the minimal existence of the individual. regarding anything exceeding the necessity for minimal existence, one must give it up for the benefit of others. Naturally, anyone who acts this way is considered to love others. Conversely, for an individual to give up his minimal needs for others is unnatural, and one can only do that once in a lifetime [i.e., it leads to death].

[1] The source of this matter, and the following sections, is in the essay "Matan Torah" (The Giving of the Torah) and "Essay for the Completion of the Zohar" by Baal HaSulam.

Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Articles / Article 4 - Religion and Nation

Man is a Social Being

Man is a social being, and he does not have the power to satisfy his needs except with the help of others. The helpless individual requires social life.

Through observation, we see that the life of a Nation resembles completely the life of an Individual, and the role of every individual resembles the role of the organs in a body.

Just as in the human body there must be full harmony between its organs—where each organ stands guard and waits to fulfill its role—so too the "organs" that constitute the body of the Nation (the advisors, the employers, the workers, etc.) must act out of full harmony. This is a necessity for the normal life of a people and for a secure existence.

Just as the natural death of a person is the result of a lack of harmony between his organs, so too the natural decline of a nation is the result of a disturbance created between its members.

Did not our Sages say (Yoma 9b): "Why was the Second Temple destroyed, seeing that they were occupied with Torah, Mitzvot, and good deeds? Because there was Baseless Hatred (Sinat Chinam) among them."

A necessary condition for the existence of a nation to be well-united is that all individuals within it be connected to one another through natural love that does not depend on a specific cause.

Not only should every individual see his own happiness in the happiness [of the nation] itself[1], and his own degeneration in the degeneration of the nation, but he must also be ready, in times of need, to sacrifice his entire self and soul for the benefit of his people. Without this condition, a nation has no right to exist, and its verdict is sealed in advance.

This does not mean that every single individual in the nation, without exception, must behave this way. The intention is that those people who feel this harmony are the ones who make the nation a nation and give it the right to exist; the happiness of the nation is measured by their quality.

Once there is a sufficient number of individuals in the nation to ensure its existence, it is permissible for there to be, to a certain extent, "withered limbs" who are not connected to the body of the nation to the necessary degree. The foundation is already secured without them.

[1] Meaning: He identifies his personal happiness entirely with the happiness of the collective.

Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Articles / Article 4 - Religion and Nation

The Foundation of the Nation – Love of Others

Now, after the Ingathering of the Exiles (Kibbutz Galuyot) in the Land of Israel, we must create a renewed fundamental national education by cultivating social love and rekindling the embers of nationalism that have dimmed over two thousand years.

Just as a healthy person is endowed with absolute control over his organs solely through the power of love, and his organs obey him with pleasure without any fear of punishment, so too must we establish here a governance based on love and instinctive devotion of the individuals to the collective.

One of the precious virtues lost to us during the years of our exile is National Consciousness—that is, the natural feeling that connects and sustains every nation. The threads of love connecting a nation, which are so natural in all other nations, have atrophied and severed from our hearts. Even the little national love that remains is not imprinted in us positively (as is normal for all nations), but rather stems from the common suffering decreed upon every member of the Jewish nation.

Thus, our national recognition and closeness are merely that of "Brothers in Distress." This is but an external factor that joined with our natural national consciousness. From this mixture arose a strange kind of national love, unfit for its role; its warmth is sufficient only for temporary enthusiasm, but it lacks the power to rebuild a self-sustaining nation. A union that exists due to an external factor is not a national union at all; we are like a bundle of separate items held together only by the sack that wraps them. This body is not united and stable; any external fluctuation affecting the "sack" stirs up friction and separation within the body.

If we know how to breathe feelings of National Love between one individual and another, and between the individual and the collective—as well as loyalty and devotion to Judaism, which were planted within us when we were on our land—we will achieve our eternal cohesion.

When we speak of National Education, we mean rooting Love between man and his fellow and between man and the entire nation.

However, this does not mean excessive, chauvinistic national love, but rather a measure sufficient to preserve the nation's existence and independence. All love exceeding this minimal measure should be dedicated to humanity as a whole, without distinction of nationality or race. The relationship between the Nation and Humanity should be the same as the relationship between the Individual and the Nation.

It is to be hoped that we have found the good kernel from which the observance of Torah and Mitzvot (as per Halacha) may grow, until we merit to attain the Light within their observance.

Into these good actions and deeds, we must instill the Divine Command present in the Mitzvah of "Love of Others": It is as if the Holy One, Blessed be He, Himself stands before every worker during his labor for the happiness of the Nation of Israel.

Meaning, the worker should expect that through this work for the benefit of his people, he will merit Adhesion (Dvekut) with God, who is the source of all Truth, Goodness, Pleasantness, and Tenderness. Then, he will feel the spiritual elevation present in every act done for the benefit of any Jew in our Holy Land.

Throughout the thousands of years of exile, we could not fulfill the Mitzvot properly and in purity to exhaust the purpose for which they were given. Now, we have been given the opportunity to purify and sanctify ourselves, to learn and toil in the desired measure, until we reach Perfection of Attainment—which is the redemption of the soul and the redemption of the body as one.

With the perfection of Knowledge (Da'at), bodies are also perfected. And when the Children of Israel attain complete Knowledge, the fountains of understanding will overflow beyond the borders of Israel and water all nations, as it is written (Isaiah 11:9): "For the earth shall be full of the knowledge of the Lord..." and (Jeremiah 31:11): "And they shall flow unto the goodness of the Lord..."[1]

[1] See the source of this matter in the Introduction to Panim Meirot u'Masbirot, section 4.

Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Articles / Article 4 - Religion and Nation

Religious and Secular

Above all, it is fitting for us to erase from our dictionary the words "Religious" (Datiyim) and "Secular" (Chilonim).

There is no such thing as a "Secular Jew" at all, and especially not in our Holy Land. And if we wish to call ourselves by any name, the correct name is "Compromisers" (Psharnim).

In the fulfillment of Torah and Mitzvot, there is a Maximum and a Minimum.

The Maximum is as it is written (Joshua 1:8): "You shall meditate on it day and night"—literally. The Sages were lenient and said that by reciting the Shema in the morning and evening, we fulfill the obligation of "You shall meditate on it day and night." However, it is clear that the Sages did not intend for a mere recitation of the Shema as lip service, but rather the fulfillment of the words said in the Shema: "And you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your might" (Deuteronomy 6:5). This is the Maximum.

The Minimum is: "A Jew, even though he has sinned, is still a Jew" (Sanhedrin 44a).

Every person fluctuates between the Maximum and the Minimum. And naturally, he judges himself favorably and compromises with a one-sided compromise.

Who would dare to say that he fulfills the commandment of "And you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart..." with consistency? If so, there is no person who recites the Shema according to its [full spiritual] law—so how can he call himself by the name "Religious"?

Consequently, we must say that either we are all "Secular," or we are all "Righteous," as it is said (Isaiah 60:21): "And Your people are all righteous."

But reality dictates that we are all Compromisers.