Articles & study materials — Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein
Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Weekly Torah Portion
Parashat Noach
"These are the generations of Noah, Noah was a righteous man, wholehearted in his generations" (Genesis 6:9).
Rashi explains this verse as follows: "Some of our Sages interpret this for praise: Certainly, had he lived in a generation of righteous people, he would have been even more righteous. And some interpret it for disparagement: In his generation, he was righteous, but had he been in the generation of Abraham, he would not have been considered anything."
At first glance, this is wondrous: Why would they interpret it for disparagement when it is possible to interpret it for the praise of a righteous and wholehearted man like Noah? Furthermore, the phrase "he would not have been considered anything" is difficult to understand.
This can be explained according to what I have already written regarding Moses our Teacher, peace be upon him (see Parashat Va'etchanan), about whom it is written: "Now the man Moses was very humble, more than any man" (Numbers 12:3).
The explanation is that Moses attained the level of Private Providence (Hashgacha Pratit), realizing that the Holy One, Blessed be He, alone performed, performs, and will perform all deeds. He felt like an axe in the hand of the chopper, as written in the prayer for the night of Yom Kippur: "Behold, like clay in the hand of the potter—if he wishes, he expands, and if he wishes, he shortens—so are we in Your hand..." Therefore, he had no room for pride or to consider himself as something; he felt that the Divine Presence (Shechinah) spoke from his throat, and he was merely like a pipe through which the abundance flowed.
Therefore, the Gemara says (Berachot 33b) regarding the verse: "And now, Israel, what does the Lord your God ask of you, but to fear..." (Deut. 10:12). The Gemara asks: "Is fear a small thing?" And it answers: "Yes, for Moses, it is a small thing."
Seemingly, this is difficult, for it is understood that the Fear of Heaven possessed by Moses is more important than the Fear of Heaven of any other person. How can the Gemara say that for Moses, fear is a small thing?
However, according to the above, it is well understood. Since his level was Humility—meaning Private Providence, knowing that God does everything—then all other attributes, such as Fear and Love (which imply a separate self that fears or loves), without the feeling that God alone does everything, are levels inferior to Humility.
Therefore, it is written (Proverbs 22:4): "The heel of humility is the fear of the Lord." And the Sages interpreted (Yerushalmi Shabbat 1:3): "What Wisdom made a crown for its head, Humility made a heel for its sole." For regarding Wisdom it is written: "The beginning of wisdom is the fear of the Lord" (Psalms 111:10)—meaning Fear is the head of Wisdom; but regarding Humility, it is written: "The heel of humility is the fear of the Lord."
Now let us return to the matter of Noah. Those who interpret for praise, it is simple: certainly, had he been in Abraham's generation, he would have been even more righteous.
And those who interpret for disparagement hold that Noah thought that had he been in Abraham's generation, he would have merited the level of Humility like Moses our Teacher. In that state, he would not have considered himself as anything (lo haya nechshav le'klum) in his own eyes, but rather like an axe in the hand of the chopper.
If so, we find that both interpret for praise. For the level of Private Providence is very great, but one must completely nullify one's selfhood and existence to attain it. Thus, the explanation of "disparagement" refers to Noah himself—that in his own eyes, he would not have considered himself to be anything. Understand this well.