Articles & study materials — Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein
Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Weekly Torah Portion
Parashat Yitro
"Now therefore, if you will listen to My voice indeed, and keep My covenant, then you shall be My own treasure (Segula) from among all peoples; for all the earth is Mine. And you shall be to Me a kingdom of priests and a holy nation. These are the words which you shall speak to the children of Israel" (Exodus 19:5-6).
Rashi explains: "No less and no more."
In these verses, it is not explained what the "Voice" is ("listen to My voice") and what the "Covenant" is. Similarly, the words "You shall be My own treasure" are ambiguous: do they connect to the preceding condition (i.e., strive to be a treasured people), or are they a promise to us that by keeping the covenant we will become a treasured people? Also, regarding "For all the earth is Mine," commentators struggle to explain the connection with "You shall be My own treasure from among all peoples."
Furthermore, the meaning of "Kingdom of Priests" requires clarification: If it means that the entire nation of Israel will be priests worthy of offering sacrifices and receiving priestly gifts, who will be the ones offering and giving? And if it means we are sanctified with the holiness of priests, it already says "and a holy nation"—so what is the distinction between "Kingdom of Priests" and "Holy Nation"?
Let us preface by explaining the matter of the Giving of the Torah in general. Why was the Torah not given to all inhabitants of the world and all nations? After all, it is written: "And the Lord shall be King over all the earth" (Zechariah 14:9), "For the earth shall be full of the knowledge of the Lord" (Isaiah 11:9), "And all nations shall flow to it" (Isaiah 2:2), "That none of us be banished" (II Samuel 14:14), and "Everything that is created, for My glory I created it" (Isaiah 43:7). Everyone will receive their correction in the end, for no worker acts without a purpose, especially the Creator. If so, why did He choose the Jewish nation alone? Is this simply racism?
The Sages said regarding this (Avodah Zarah 2b) that the Holy One, Blessed be He, offered it to every nation and tongue, and they did not accept it, until He came to Israel and they accepted it. If so, one could ask: Why are we called the "Chosen People" ("The Lord chose you" - Deut. 7:6), if none of the other nations wanted to accept it? Also, why was the Torah not given to our forefathers Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, who fulfilled it before it was given?
The matter is that the foundation of our Holy Torah is the Love of Others (Ahavat HaZulat). [As explained previously regarding Aaron and Moses partnering to instill "Love your neighbor as yourself"].
For this reason, the Torah was not given to the Patriarchs, but rather delayed until the Exodus from Egypt, when they became a complete nation of 600,000 men aged twenty and up. Each one was asked if he agreed to this sublime work—to work together in true love for the sake of every single one of the 600,000 members. After everyone answered and said: "All that the Lord has spoken we will do" (Exodus 19:8)—immediately the Torah was given to them.
Although there is no doubt that the purpose of creation is for the benefit of all humanity... due to the descent of human nature into self-love which rules over it without limits, there was no way to negotiate with the other nations to agree to leave their narrow framework of self-love for the broad world of love of others. They all asked "What is written in it?" because they were immersed in the filth of self-love...
Except for the Nation of Israel, because the servitude in Egypt preceded them for several hundred years, with great and terrible suffering which cleanses and brings great purification to a person. Additionally, the purification of the Holy Patriarchs stood for them, from Abraham who was the Chariot of Chesed (Loving-kindness).
Therefore, the Torah calls them in the singular form "And Israel encamped (Vayichan) there," and the Sages explained: "As one man with one heart." Because every individual of the nation completely withdrew from self-love, and his sole intention was only for the benefit of society in mutual help and love. Their success was assured when each one knew that 600,000 loyal friends stood by his side... ensuring he would lack nothing of his needs.
Because of this, it was necessary to give the Torah specifically to the People of Israel... However, the People of Israel were established as a sort of "Treasure" (Segula) or remedy, to pass sparks of purification to all of humanity... until they too develop to understand and feel the pleasantness and tranquility hidden in the love of others. Then "all nations shall flow to it."
Now the verses are understood simply:
"If you will listen to My voice... then you shall be My own treasure": Through you, sparks of purification will pass to all nations.
"For all the earth is Mine": All nations belong to Me, and they are destined to reach perfection, but currently they are not yet capable of this lofty role, so I need a "Treasured People."
"And you shall be to Me a Kingdom of Priests": This expresses the form of the work. Just as priests have no portion or inheritance, only God is their inheritance, so too the nation will be organized such that the whole earth is holy to God, and no individual deals with it except to fulfill the needs of the collective... In this way, no individual needs to worry for his own needs. Even secular work like sowing and reaping is considered actual holiness, like the service of priests in the Temple. For one who reaps his field to feed another is like one offering a sacrifice to God.
"And a Holy Nation": Through adhesion to God, we become holy... knowing God with clear knowledge, just as a person knows himself and has no doubt of his own existence.
"And all the people answered together" (Exodus 19:8). They did not wait for one another, but everyone answered from the truth in his heart, accepting the responsibility to be a "Light unto the Nations" (Segula). And regarding the acceptance of the yoke of commandments, they answered a second time: "We will do and we will hear" (Exodus 24:7).