Articles & study materials — Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein
Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Weekly Torah Portion
Parashat Pinchas
"Pinchas, the son of Eleazar..." (Numbers 25:11).
It is written in the Midrash (Yalkut Shimoni, Pinchas 771): "Rabbi Shimon ben Lakish said: Pinchas is Elijah."
This is puzzling, for it should have said "Elijah is Pinchas," since Pinchas lived long before Elijah, and usually, the later figure is attributed to the earlier one[1].
First, we must clarify why Elijah is called the "Angel of the Covenant" (Malach HaBrit). Similarly, in the Mohel's prayer, he says: "Elijah, Angel of the Covenant, stand at my right hand, here is yours before you."
This is difficult: Do we not bless at a circumcision "to enter him into the Covenant of Abraham our Father"? If so, why is Elijah called the Angel of the Covenant? And what is the meaning of "Here is yours before you"? Why does this commandment belong to Elijah, given that we received the commandment of circumcision from the days of Abraham?
There are also statements by the Sages that require explanation:
In one place, it is written that we must prepare a special chair for Elijah, called "The Chair of Elijah," and we must verbally declare "This is the Chair of Elijah, remembered for good"; otherwise, he does not come (see Zohar Introduction, section 225).
Yet in another place (Zohar Lech Lecha, section 388), it is written that because Elijah said "I have been very zealous for the Lord... for the Children of Israel have forsaken Your covenant" (1 Kings 19:14), God said to him: "By your life! Wherever my children make this holy mark in their flesh, you will be present there. And the mouth that testified that Israel forsook the covenant shall testify that Israel is keeping this covenant."
Thus, Elijah is obligated to be at every Brit Milah as a punishment for speaking slander against Israel. How does this align with the idea that we must prepare a chair and invite him, or else he won't come? He is compelled to come and testify! Furthermore, why is this testimony needed? Is not everything revealed and known before the Holy One, Blessed be He?
The explanation is this: The Children of Israel never actually forsook the commandment of circumcision. Rather, what Elijah meant by "They have forsaken Your covenant" is a deep secret.
The commandment of circumcision is in the aspect of a Sacrifice (Korban). In all sacrifices, it is known that a portion was given to the Sitra Achra (the Other Side/Evil Inclination), causing it to turn from an accuser into a defender[3]. In the Brit Milah, the Orlah (foreskin) that is cut and cast to the dust is seen by the Sitra Achra as its portion of the sacrifice.
Since spiritual entities are intermingled, and the Orlah was once attached to the Yesod (Foundation/Holy Covenant), when it is cut off, it takes with it a part of holiness and a spark of life from the child's body to which it was attached. Since we cast the foreskin to the external forces, they suckle some illumination from the Mochin (Lights) revealed through the Circumcision (Milah) and Uncovering (Pri'ah). Therefore, they do not want to accuse Israel and disrupt these Lights, so as not to lose their portion.
Elijah could not tolerate this arrangement ("correction"). Even though the external forces cease accusing Israel, they still take a portion of the spark of holy life. Therefore, he took it upon himself to be present at every Brit to precede the Sitra Achra and take that holy spark, ensuring it does not go to the Sitra Achra.
This is why the Mohel says "Here is yours before you"—referring to the Holy Spark attached to the foreskin, which Elijah is to take hold of. This is an addition to the commandment of Abraham's covenant. The Chair we prepare is to bring Elijah's inspiration to capture this spark.
Similarly, regarding Pinchas, it is written "Because he was zealous for his God (L'Elokav)" (Num 25:13). It does not say "For the Lord" or "For God" (L'Elokim), but L'Elokav—which has the same letters as L'Eliyahu (For Elijah). For he too was zealous for the holy drop that was being handed over to the Klipah (Shell). Therefore, "Pinchas is Elijah" hints at the name Elokav written regarding Pinchas.
The verse concludes, "And he made atonement for the Children of Israel." This serves as a support for what is written in holy books: that all who participate in the commandment of Brit Milah merit atonement for their sins.
[1] See Kedushat Levi: At the moment Pinchas was zealous, his soul flew from him, and the soul of Elijah entered him...
[2] The Zohar explains: Elijah was punished for speaking against his children (Israel).
[3] See Zohar Noach 204; Pinchas 214.