Writings — Rabbi Moshe Yair Weinstock
Writings of the Disciples of Baal HaSulam / Rabbi Moshe Yair Weinstock
Why is it forbidden to use Hanukkah lights, but with Shabbat lights it is a mitzvah to enjoy them?
"The sons of understanding are the eight days." For the Greeks defiled all the oils over which they had the ability to rule. But one cruse of oil, which is drawn from the single light, they were not able to rule over. And through this the miracle was made. For there are two Shabbats: one Shabbat before the six days of work, and one Shabbat after the six days of work. And the difference is—for the Shabbat after the days of work, the days of work serve as a preparation for Shabbat, but the Shabbat before the days of work is holiness, and the klipah has no ability to rule.
And behold, tzarich iyun (it requires analysis): Why is it forbidden to use Hanukkah lights, but with Shabbat lights is it a mitzvah to enjoy them? And this is as stated—for Shabbat is only an awakening from above (hit'aruta de-le'eila), and therefore it is written, "They shall be satisfied and delight in Your goodness." For in every single thing, after satiety the pleasure ends there; but not so Shabbat, which is above, where everything is to bestow contentment (nachat ruach) before Him, and therefore even after satiety there is pleasure. And because it is only an awakening from above, therefore one can enjoy it, for indeed one does not receive at all, and understand this. But regarding Hanukkah lights, behold, there was the miracle where from that single day it spread to all seven days, and it became seven times seven, which are the forty-nine of the fifty gates of Binah, and it is like the expansion of the Shabbat before the six days of work; therefore it is forbidden to enjoy them.