Writings of Baal HaSulam / Articles / Various Matters
The Distinction Between Imagination and Intellect The imagination possesses what the intellect does not, in that the imagination brings forth and creates something from nothing (Yesh Me'Ayin). This is not so with the intellect, which merely adds, connects, or clarifies from what is already laid before it, and there is nothing new. And the intellect possesses what the imagination does not, in that the purpose of the intellect returns to itself. This is not so with the imagination, whose purpose is not in itself but in its companion—meaning, in the tastes of feeling, bitter and sweet, for the sake of which it was created. And understand that the value of the imagination is like a vessel and a pitcher, for there is no purpose or account within the vessel itself, as it is written (Avot 4:27): "Do not look at the pitcher," etc.[1]. Therefore, the imagination is not weakened by falsehood. When a false imagination is portrayed to a person, even though he knows it is false, he nevertheless derives pleasure from it as from a true imagination. It is the way of the poor to imagine to themselves that they are rich, and they immediately enjoy these depictions even though they recognize their falsehood. The reason is that the Creator, may He be blessed, did not instill in it the matter of truth and falsehood at all, but only the feelings of bitter and sweet.
The Use of Imagination - For Pleasure from the Past and Not for Sorrow And by this, the invention of contemporary doctors can be answered: for every weakness in the flesh, they immediately perform an "excision" (amputation/surgery) and cast the bad flesh from the body. This is unlike the early doctors, who would spend much time trying to restore the bad flesh to good. For seemingly, the invention of "excision" has no root in medicine according to the Wisdom of Truth, where all bad returns to good. However, you must understand that the aspect of medicine is also divided into internality and externality. Meaning, the flow of blood in the nerves is internality, while the nerves and the flesh are externality. Their root is from the intellect and the aspect of the First Nine [Sefirot], and the imagination and the aspect of Malchut. Therefore, it is a pleasant sign to cut, for this is the secret of choice given to man. By way of allegory: past events (Overot) do not relate to the body at all, and what has passed is absent (Ayin). Rather, it is the nature of the power of imagination to pain or delight a person from past events as well. And this is what we said, that the power of imagination is to bring forth something from nothing (Yesh Me'Ayin), for the past events are already in absence and are nothing. Nevertheless, the imagination brings them near, renews them, and feels them as if they are present and happening now. For it has no concern for itself; it emerged only to provide feeling. And the wise man should engage the power of imagination only to bring near the pleasure from past events, and he will enjoy them greatly, and here he shall not use his intellect nor see its falsehood before him. And [he must] distance all aspects of sorrow from the past events, as in truth they are already found in absence, and regarding these, he should specifically use his intellect. And this is truly the root for the invention of the doctors in the aspect of excising the bad flesh, and consequently, the body will return to its goodness and health. By way of allegory: A father taught his son a wondrous craft using toothed pincers, and bequeathed the pincers to him. The son forgot the craft, and later added to his foolishness by testing the pincers on his throat and slaughtering himself. There is no fool or madman greater than he. The same applies to the power of imagination: if it is true that the Creator, may He be blessed, instilled within it the extraction of something from nothing, and it is a wondrous pincer—however, the wise man will create with it specifically the pleasure, and that you shall create and consume. What need is there to create damaging creatures and bring them forth from nothingness and absence? And this is a faithful sign for the invention of excision.
Explanation of Klipat Noga And by this, you will understand Klipat Noga, which is half good and half evil. And one might question: Is not spirituality divided according to aspects and numbered by them? If so, since there is good and evil in Noga, then there are two aspects of Noga and not one. With the aforementioned, you will understand. By way of allegory, a man saw in his dream that a massive inheritance fell to him from his father, and he took much delight in the profits, great honor, and the like. During the dream, he did not feel the aspect of death at all, for such is the nature of a dream to imagine two opposites. Whichever one we desire rules with all its might, and its opposite is null and void as if it never existed. Afterwards, when he woke from his sleep and the intellect joined with the imagination, he then makes a calculation: if there is an inheritance, there is also death. Then he fasts a "dream fast" and cannot take any delight in his good dream. Examine this closely. And it is written (Proverbs 5:5): "Her feet go down to death." For the final aspect of Malchut of Atzilut is clothed in the good of Noga, and the good in the bad, and the bad in the four impure Klipot (shells), which are ABiYA of Klipa, in the secret of "God has made the one as well as the other" (Ecclesiastes 7:14). And from the First Nine [Sefirot] extends the brain of ChaBaD in intellect and knowledge, and from Malchut extends the power of imagination, in the secret of "I have used similitudes (Adameh) by the ministry of the prophets" (Hosea 12:11). With this you will understand that the aspect of the posterior (Achorayim) of the power of imagination in Malchut is clothed in the good and evil within Noga. And see above, that the power of imagination is something from nothing (Yesh Me'Ayin), and a false imagination invents a feeling just like a true one, for it is not defined by truth and falsehood at all, as mentioned above. And this is certain, that in the aspect of Malchut of Atzilut itself, no evil feeling ruled on account of the power of ChHG[2], as it is written (Psalms 5:5): "Evil shall not dwell with You." There, only the good feeling and the Light that grew from the power of imagination created anew ruled. However, when this form later came on its own and clothed itself in Noga, then Noga mimicked holiness like a monkey before a human. For the monkey possesses a natural desire that acts from its imaginative brain, after which all the wisdom of the monkey is drawn. This is not the case with humans, for they too act from the imaginative brain, but in combination with their speculative intellectual brain; understand this. Therefore, at the time when Noga clothes the power of imagination within the Malchut that is clothed within it, it brings forth great pleasure and Light; thus it is called Noga, which translates to Light. But when Noga spreads below to clothe itself in A"A of Klipa, it is likened to that man who wakes from his sleep and calculates regarding his dream that an inheritance comes from a death. He finds himself terrified by his dream, taking pleasure and suffering simultaneously. This is the secret of the mixture of good and evil together within Noga that is clothed in A"A of Klipa. And the matter of ABiYA of Klipa: The four impure Klipot are the secret of the ten Sefirot of impurity, like the First Nine and Malchut. And Malchut is the Assiyah of impurity, and she is called the dregs of the Klipot, and a kingdom without a crown (Malchuta be-la Taga). The matter is that the First Nine draw forth the speculative and intellectual brain, and within them, there is a mixture of good and evil. This is not so with Malchut, which is the feeling that reacts solely from the imaginative power without any speculation or knowledge. Like the aforementioned dreamer, whose father's death terrifies him greatly; he sits in a dream fast, afraid to think or remember the event of the dream, neither its honey nor its sting, and only the images of death stand and terrify him. And this is what they said regarding the letter Kof (ק), whose leg extends downwards in the secret of "her feet go down to death." For this monkey (Kof / קוף) is nothing but an emotional reaction from the imagination alone, and it stands on one leg, meaning the aspect of Malchut without the First Nine—that is, the power of ChRH"G and its form without the illumination connected to this power. And "falsehood has no feet" (Shikra la kai) means that this power of imagination is false. And one should not question, "But is it not written 'God has made the one as well as the other'?" For it is truly a force, meaning it provides feeling, and it is inappropriate to ponder regarding a force whether it is true or false. Rather, it is appropriate to ponder what measure of bitter or sweet feeling it contains; do not look at the pitcher, but at what is in it. And with this you will understand that Noga is truly one aspect, meaning illumination alone, like the pleasure of an inheritance. But when it extends to illuminate downwards to the Partzufim of the Klipot, they automatically mimic like a monkey before a human. That is, they calculate with their wisdom and understanding that through this they draw only the imaginative power of ChHG, like the judgment of the one who awakes from his sleep, that death comes first and inheritance follows. And since they truly have no knowledge to understand that the entire imagination is false and is nothing but a force to illuminate this truth itself, they fall into the dregs of the Klipot, which is the entire force of the governance of this world. * And here you see the secret of the Ascent, which is nothing other than not dirtying one's feet in Klipat Noga, in the secret of the verse (Ecclesiastes 5:1): "Guard your foot when you go to the house of God." Until the dregs of the Klipot enact and reveal all the potential they have, and then the power of holiness begins in the aspect of thought, as it is written (Deuteronomy 4:29): "But from there you will seek... and you will find." For the wickedness of the chariot of a worthless man (Adam Bliya'al) and the goodness of a holy man (Adam de-Kedusha) are revealed in the aspect of ascending upward. In this, the souls emerge to clothe their 613 Tzelems (images). Through these clarifications (Birurin), which are the secret of the expansion of the brain of Da'at, the four impure Klipot are swallowed into the evil within Noga, for their wickedness is revealed. And afterwards, the evil is swallowed into the good within Noga, and it is revealed retroactively that it is nothing but a force and feeling prepared solely to illuminate. And then, "the brightness (Noga) shall be as the light" (Habakkuk 3:4). And the secret of the swallowing of evil into good is similar to the aspect of "excision" in the wisdom of medicine. For all the sorrow in the Klipot fell into the aspect of past events and absence. And there is a work in this not to allow the imaginative brain to create something from nothing—meaning, for the feelings of sorrow in the past events that are already absent, and what is past is nothing. And by the effort to invent something from nothing in the aspect of past events to bring near all the good that has passed, one finds in this the swallowing of evil into good. Understand this well. * And by this, you will understand the secret of the peeling of the rods that Jacob performed in Laban's house. For once Joseph was born, Jacob wanted to return to his father's house. Laban then tied himself to him and showed him that all his wondrous success (which was drawn by the power of ChRH"G) would go to waste. This is similar to what is found regarding the Men of the Great Assembly who imprisoned the evil inclination, and a day-old egg was not to be found; understand this. And regarding this, he wanted to kill Messiah ben Joseph, saying, "Name your wages to me, and I will give it" (Genesis 30:28), which our Sages interpreted (Zohar, Vayetze 294) as "a female (Nekevah / Name) is your wage," and this is sufficient for the understanding one. Against this, our father Jacob, peace be upon him, acted wisely and told him that he did not need his Nukva (female) at all. This is his statement, "Remove from there every speckled and spotted one among the sheep, and the brown among the goats" (Genesis 30:32). To show him that he does not need to sacrifice to demons in their heat, in the secret of "Aha, I am warm, I have seen the fire" (Isaiah 44:16), which is the secret of the "brown" (Chum / heat) in the goats. Rather, what did our father Jacob do? He took rods and peeled them, and "when the flocks conceived, he set their faces toward the rods" (Genesis 30:41)—meaning, in mere imagination. And even though it is a false imagination, for Joseph had already been born, nevertheless, the imagination reveals the feeling and the heat even in a false imagination, and this is sufficient for the understanding one. And from these peeled rods, he amassed greater wealth than he had previously made for Laban's flock in actual Nukva; understand this. Yet nevertheless, "An Aramean destroying my father," for "he saw the face of Laban, and behold, it was not toward him as before" (Genesis 31:2). Meaning, in the world of A"K and the world of Atzilut, which is the secret of "He will revive us after two days" (Hosea 6:2), in the secret of "If there is no wound, why do I need healing?" (based on Sanhedrin 101a), and "whose mouth speaks vanity" (Psalms 144:11), and there is no wound. Consequently, it is found that their right hand, which is the secret of the Light and healing in the power of the right, is a right hand of falsehood. And because of this, he fled from him, for he wanted to perform an excision and cast away entirely the feelings of sorrow from the past events. Laban pursued him, but could not speak to him either good or bad, as it is written (Genesis 31:29): "the God of your father spoke to me yesternight (Emesh), saying, Take heed that you speak not," etc. Meaning, "yesternight" is the secret of the form of ChH"G itself, and it itself told him this. Thus, his only claim was, "why have you stolen my gods?" (Genesis 31:30)—meaning, the form of ChRH"G, from which he lost all his success, as is known. And "Jacob did not know that Rachel had stolen them" (Genesis 31:32), and he pinned the blame on Laban himself, that God no longer wished to grant him success. Thus he cursed, "With whomever you find your gods, let him not live." However, Rachel sat on the Teraphim (idols) and no longer had the way of women, and she lied to her father, claiming, "for the way of women is upon me" (Genesis 31:35). And this was the cause of Rachel's death when she had hard labor delivering Benjamin, and therefore she called him Ben-Oni (son of my sorrow) (Genesis 35:18). However, Jacob later corrected this curse and once again revealed the power of the illumination of the right hand, acting with might and strength, and therefore he called him Ben-Yamin (son of the right hand). Understand all this exceedingly well, for I have been very brief, and a hint is sufficient for the wise. Examine further, that Laban called the nullification of the form of ChH"G "Yegar Sahaduta", in the manner of "Ben-Oni"; Yegar is from the language of fear. But Jacob called it "Gal-Ed"; Gal from the word revealed (Gila), for he had great joy that everything lost to Laban the Aramean returned and was revealed. Understand this in the manner of Ben-Yamin. And understand the names "Lach", "Luz", and "Armon". "Lach" (moist) is moisture, which is the building in the place of the Nukva[3] that has not yet coagulated, and this is sufficient. "Luz" (almond) is the revelation of the Nukva and the coagulation of the stones. Luz is related to the deviation of lips (Lazut Sefatayim), "and the name of the city was formerly Luz" (Genesis 28:19), "when vileness (Zulut) is exalted among the sons of men" (Psalms 12:8). And "Armon" (chestnut) is from the language of cunning (Orma), for all of this is nothing but cunning alone. Alternatively, Armon is the wisdom in the unification of Ankatam, which was sufficient to be awake (Er) from his sleep, which is the secret of the eyes of Yesod; and this is sufficient for the understanding one.
[1] "Do not look at the pitcher, but at what is in it." [2] Needs further study to decipher the acronym. And from the places mentioned later, it seems that ChH"G is the power of imagination in a dream. [3] Perhaps the acronym stands for: The place of the Nukva (Mekom HaNukva).