Writings of Baal HaSulam / Articles / The Land of Israel
"For they are stronger than we (lit. than He)" (Numbers 13:31). It is known that the entire prolongation of the exile is due to the sin of the spies. They were the first to prolong it—from days to years—and they are the latter ones to prolong it, and who knows until when, God forbid. Therefore, we must explain this sin at its root.
Behold, the revelation of their claim, "For they are stronger than we/He," demands investigation. Since they were, in this regard, like a rabbinic court (Beit Din), where two were acquitting and ten were condemning, what then were those "orphans" (the generation of the wilderness) to do? The Torah had already been given to the land, dictating, "incline after the majority" (Exodus 23:2), and all the more so after a court selected by the mouth of the Lord, by Moses, and by all of Israel, for each was a chosen leader and a prince of his tribe. And if you wish to say they themselves sinned—how did all of Israel sin?
And one cannot say that they should have listened to our teacher Moses, for the Oral Torah is also from Sinai, and they had already heard it. Thus, even a prophet cannot permanently annul a single matter [of the Torah], except as a temporary measure (Maimonides, Hilchot Yesodei HaTorah 9:3). Yet here, the matter was permanent. Nor can one distinguish Moses as the greatest of the prophets [to give him an exception], for all the more so he could not annul his own words.
The answer is simple. The principle of "incline after the majority" applies only to matters involving doubt and deliberation. This is not the case regarding the conquest of the Land, which was the primary condition of the exodus from Egypt—to reach a land flowing with milk and honey. Therefore, one who deliberates on this is nothing but a heretic. Meaning, one does not appoint a court over this, over the establishment of the Torah and faith in their essence, for "Abraham was one" (Ezekiel 33:24), and this is simple.
With this we will understand that Moses’ sending [of the spies] and his intention was for a temporary deliberation, for the timing was not stated by the mouth of the Lord. Thus, even if they had answered "no" [for that moment], then even Moses himself could have annulled it, as a prophet may suspend a matter of Torah as a temporary measure. This is subject to deliberation, and over this they had the status of a court, and "incline after the majority" would apply. And so it was.
Therefore, they [the spies] understood that if they said it was only for the moment, Israel would not accept it from them, for a prophet can uproot a matter from the Torah temporarily based on an individual opinion. So they acted cunningly and said, "For they are stronger than we (than He) etc.—even the Master of the house cannot remove His vessels from there" (Sotah 35a). Consequently, the Satan succeeded, because Israel did not want to transgress their judgment, since they had been sent on the condition of listening only to the majority. The argument of Joshua and Caleb—that they were denying the entirety of the Torah—was not accepted by them, due to the righteousness of the princes, who were "called of the congregation, men of renown," and were not suspected of this.
And the nature of their error, given that these men of renown were the chosen of the Lord, is a sublime matter. For it is a rule that human understanding is the opposite of the understanding of the Torah, as it is said (Isaiah 55:8), "My thoughts are not your thoughts," etc. Now, regarding the land chosen for Israel by the mouth of the Lord, human understanding dictates that it should be the best of lands, with the finest air, etc., for it was not chosen for nothing, etc. Yet, when they looked at this place, behold, an inversion: not only was it not the best, but the complete opposite; they fell from a high roof into a deep pit.
The reason is simple. Everything rules most powerfully at its root. Therefore, since this world is rooted in the Land of Israel, are not all the impurities of the world rooted here? Conversely, in its expansion [outside Israel], it is divided into seventy ministers, and the impurity of one is not like the impurity of another; thus, each impurity is only one part of seventy. Not so in their root, where they are all gathered together as one.
This is why they said, "and we were in our own sight as grasshoppers," etc. (Numbers 13:33). For they saw such Klipot (shells/impurities) that they had never imagined, as if born instantly, all at once. "And their cities are fortified up to heaven" (Numbers 13:28), for such is the nature of the Klipa before the battle with them: in the imagination, they appear as giants.