Rabbi Binyamin Sinkovsky / Parashot / Parashat Bereshit
"In the beginning God created" At the Kiddush of Parashat Bereshit, 5711 (1950)
He said: A beautiful Midrash — because of the wickedness of the nations of the world, who at that time would say to Israel, "You are robbers" [Listim atem], we merited the portions of Bereshit [Genesis] and Shemot [Exodus]. For if not for this, we would be lacking, and our Torah would have started from "This month shall be unto you," as Rabbi Yitzchak stated.
But the question arises: Even with Bereshit, the nations will not believe, since they do not believe in the Torah anyway. So what do we gain from the portion of Bereshit and the portion detailing how the Holy One, blessed be He, created everything and gave it to whomever He wished? Rather, the answer is... for ourselves, and then they will not say "they are robbers."
The Five Books of the Torah correspond to KaCha"B Tu"M [Keter, Chochmah, Binah, Tiferet, and Malchut] or ChaGa"T Ne"H [Chesed, Gevurah, Tiferet, Netzach, Hod]. Thus: Bereshit is Chesed [Right Line], Shemot is Gevurah [Left Line], Vayikra is Tiferet [Middle Line], Bamidbar and Devarim are Yesod and Malchut.
And this is what Rabbi Yitzchak meant: Because the nations of the world say to us, "You are robbers," since the Middle Line only comes about through the inclusion of the two lines, Right and Left (from the Left of the Right and the Right of the Left), and it has nothing of its own at all; its entire essence comes from the two lines together. This is the essence of their claim. And the answer is: "In the beginning God created" [Bereshit bara Elokim]—meaning the entire concept of their existence is conditional, coming only to serve the Reshit [the "Beginning"/Israel]. And without the Reshit, you [the nations/the Left] are nothing but secondary and unnecessary.
Now, this entire answer is good for the Future to Come [L'Atid Lavo], when even the nations will believe in the Torah. But now, since they do not believe in the Torah, what good does it do to tell them Bereshit? Rather, the very possibility of such a question existing... is a reason... for the Creator to start the Torah from Bereshit. For without this, we would not have acquired the first two books, Bereshit and Shemot, which represent the two lines: Right and Left.
And the question is deeper than it appears regarding Rabbi Yitzchak's statement brought by Rashi, of blessed memory: "If the nations say" — meaning the nations of the world at the End of Correction [Gmar Tikkun], when there will no longer be a need for the correction of the Middle Line because the Left Line will also be corrected. "You are robbers" — meaning that even after the End of Correction, Israel will not abandon the Middle Line, but will continue as they did before the End of Correction, out of will and truth. And then the nations of the world will say to them: "You are robbers, for there is no substance or existence to the Middle Line that is... without us." We answer them: "In the beginning He created" — for then they will believe in the Torah, and thus the very possibility of their retroactive question gave us two additional books in the Torah.
The Inner Meaning (Pnimiut) of the Matter: The concept of the Land of Israel having seven nations there beforehand is merely the result of creating the possibility of choosing good. And in order for this possibility to exist, evil must be there beforehand, so there is room for choice. And this is: "If the nations of the world say you are robbers" — meaning, your [Middle] Line is not originally yours in its own right; rather, its ownership was ours, and you took it from us, merely mixing its direction and color, but before the change, it was ours.
We answer them: "In the beginning He created" — meaning the entire earth belongs to the Holy One, blessed be He. He created everything, and there is no change in Him. Rather, out of His love for His treasured people — "He has declared to His people the power of His works, to give them the heritage of the nations" — meaning the entire existence of good and evil only came about "to give them the heritage of the nations": to give them the ability to despise evil and choose good. Therefore, there was a prior necessity to invent you, to create you, you who hold the line of evil, so that Israel would have something to despise and something to choose. You only came to serve them. The entire purpose of your existence is only to make room for them and help them, but I did not invent you for your own sake, for your own aspect; therefore, you are silenced and removed. However, in the meantime, from the possibility of their appeal and complaints—the reality of opposition and violation—we merited two additional books in the Torah.