Conversations with Baal HaSulam
Before the Deed: Reward and Punishment; After the Deed: Private Providence
(The State of Israel, Ben-Gurion, and Agudat Yisrael)
Regarding internal matters, he conveyed his opinion to me:
That "So-and-so" is considered by him an apostate, and "Such-and-such" is terribly gluttonous, having no foundation or idea, only gluttony of the worst kind. And so are they all—receiving from the worst kind.
Therefore, from the "Lesser of Evils," he chose then to support David Ben-Gurion.
For ultimately, he [Ben-Gurion] does not receive for himself, but worries—according to his understanding—for the Collective (Klal). He is the "Bad," but the lesser one.
I remarked to him: "This is specifically difficult, for does not this good go only to the Sitra Achra (Other Side)?"
He said to me: "It is forbidden to tell too much, but this is the matter of 'Lo Lishma' (Not for Her sake).
And this 'Lo Lishma' is like the matter of a Palace and a Tower filled with all good things, which one cannot reach except via a Corridor.
There, in the corridor, they shoot with weapons of destruction at anyone who wants to pass through, and one cannot reach the Palace except through the corridor, where anyone passing through risks his life.
Now, the 'Lo Lishma' of Ben-Gurion is before the Corridor; he has not even reached the corridor yet. Meaning, it is an External 'Lo Lishma'.
But Agudat Yisrael—they are found inside the Corridor, and they receive terrible blows from the Sitra Achra—an Internal 'Lo Lishma'."
"Either way, there is no one for whom to take Jerusalem. For into whose hand shall we deliver it? Into the hand of Ben-Gurion and Moshe Sharett? Will they build the Holy Temple? I do not see faithful, worthy hands."
I said: "But the Holy One, Blessed be He, does not do things by halves. Surely He has already prepared for us such souls that will appear soon, and they will be worthy of it."
He remained silent, and then said:
"Der Oibershter zol helfin, altz tut der Oibershter..."
[The Holy One, Blessed be He, will help. The Holy One, Blessed be He, does everything. He even sends down the sins (Aveirot), like "Tzadiki b'nosseh alilah" (God orchestrating a pretext).
But first, one must go through 'Reward and Punishment' (Schar v'Onesh).
Only afterwards does one see that the Creator does everything.
But if one does not walk the path of Reward and Punishment first—may the Creator save us—one falls.
However, when one walks the path of Reward and Punishment first, the Creator helps later, and one merits to see that everything is the Creator—'He alone did, does, and will do all deeds.'
But first—Reward and Punishment. First through 'Lo Lishma' with all the falling and rising.
And only afterwards—Private Providence, even [regarding] the sins.]