Writings of Baal HaSulam / Articles / Man and His Freedom / Freedom of Opinions
The freedom of the individual is not in corporeality: From the proof in the article Scientific Research on Servitude to Him (Article 10, "Peace," Item 12), where we proved from nature itself that a person is obligated to connect with society, and this connection subjugates the individual to bestow upon society. Nature itself obligates him and robs him of his freedom, and this is the law by which the many justly compel the minority to accept upon themselves the teachings founded on science from life's experiences, to the same extent that the survival of society depends on them.
The freedom of the individual remains in full force regarding freedom of opinions: Since the aforementioned matter of bestowal is a commandment that applies to one's body—meaning that one is obligated to sustain the bodily life of society, over which the nature of connection alone holds sway—whereas spiritual needs, upon which the survival of the body does not depend, certainly do not obligate a person to societal life, for one can exist without any knowledge at all, like a primitive beast. Therefore, the many have no justification to rob the individual's freedom regarding opinions.
Halacha and Aggadah: "The individual and the many, the Halacha is according to the many" (Berakhot 9a). Now, this law, despite all its shortcomings (which are explained in Article The Freedom, Item 60), came to us by way of the commandment of Providence, for we have no orderly conduct of life without it. This itself is the obligation for its preservation, for there is no commandment and obligation greater than the obligation of the law of nature and the necessity of life.
However, this applies only to laws concerning bodily arrangements. But as for matters removed from any bodily harm, this law certainly has no right to exist, and this is the distinction between Halacha and Aggadah.
The corporeal will-to-receive must be obliterated — the spiritual will-to-receive must remain: And it has been explained that the particular will-to-receive, which is the entire essence of the individual person, must be obliterated for the sake of society's happiness and success, whereas the will-to-receive regarding opinions is eternal even in its individuality, and if it is eternal, it possesses individual freedom as well, since this is its character.
Unlike the corporeal will-to-receive, which has no right to exist in isolation, but only within a complete society—the state or the world—and therefore society has the power to nullify it.
From this, you will understand how much the Russians erred in that they negated even freedom of opinion, for this is a criminal offense. Since opinion is not necessary for the survival of society, society has no permission to rob it and take away its individual character. Therefore, all national cultures must be preserved in their entirety, both in religion and in customs. Only whatever touches or harms the collective body should be destroyed, and nothing more at all.
[Gloss: From here you will perceive the point of weakness of the Fascists and Communists, for they stood to completely destroy individual freedom even from the standpoint of intellect and opinions, and they want the opinions of all members of society not to flow in any direction in the world other than into the Fascist or Bolshevik bowl. For this is an unpardonable yoke—meaning they have no right to exist, for it is not in vain that the Creator imprinted in every creature to live a life of freedom for itself under its own authority, until it is the most precious thing in life. It is true that the many have the right to rob the individual's freedom regarding bodies, and even to limit freedom of opinion to the extent that it does not harm the bodily life of the many, but not to impose upon them a complete government without any limit, and to turn all opinions in the state into a single mash and enslaved servants serving the bodily life of society. This is against nature, and Providence will not forgive them, for everything moves forward and not backward, and they want to push the intellect backward, and to arrest its growth, development, and evolution, as written (Article "The Freedom," Item 73, see also Article 87) that the unification of opinions is their ruin, destruction... and the halting of its propagation and multiplication, just as separation and dispute is the ruin of bodies].