Articles & study materials — Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein
Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Festivals
Hanukkah
The well-known question is: Why was the miracle established over the oil and not over the victory in war ("the strong were delivered into the hands of the weak," etc.)?
The answer is that Oil (Shemen) alludes to Wisdom (Chochmah) (see Zohar Tzav, section 164-5), as it is written: "The soul of man is the candle of the Lord" (Proverbs 20:27). The Light of Wisdom is called Chaya (Life), in the secret of "Wisdom preserves the life of him who has it" (Ecclesiastes 7:12), and Chacham (Wise) has the same gematria as Chayim (Life).
There is a hint to this from the vessels of the Tabernacle. After Bezalel arranged everything, Moses came and anointed them with the Anointing Oil, and only then did they become holy vessels. This proves that the oil hints at the Holy Spirit (Ruach HaKodesh) drawn down with the anointing oil, which is why it is called "Holy Anointing Oil" (Exodus 30:25).
Therefore, when the wicked Greek kingdom rose against us to make us forget the commandments of our Holy Torah (which is our life), and told us to "Write on the horn of an ox that you have no portion in the God of Israel" (Genesis Rabbah 2:4)—the Hasmoneans were filled with zeal for the Lord of Hosts. They entered the camp of the Greeks and struck them right and left.
This "awakening from below" made a great impression in Heaven: seeing how the Children of Israel sacrificed their souls for the Sanctification of God's Name, saying "Without the Torah and its commandments, why do we need life?"—a great miracle was performed for them, and they overcame the enemies.
Therefore, we commemorate the miracle specifically with Oil, which hints at "The soul of man is the candle of the Lord."
It is written in Sha'ar HaKavanot (regarding Hanukkah) that the complete unification (Yichud) of "Ner" (Candle/Lamp - נר) involves six Names:
YHWH-EHYEH (Numerical value: 47)
YHWH-ELOHIM (Numerical value: 112)
YHWH-ADONAI (Numerical value: 91)Together, these sums equal 250 (47+112+91 = 250), which is the gematria of Ner (נר = 50+200 = 250).This is the secret of Head, Inner, and End of the spiritual structure (Zon). Sometimes there is a unification of only the Head, or only the Inner part, but one who merits the Complete Unification unites them all, totaling "Ner."
Also, in these six Names of unification, there are 25 letters. This is the meaning of Chanu-Kah (Resting-25): The great light of the three mentioned unifications rested (Chanu) upon the people of Israel through the 25 letters (Kah). We awaken these lights to shine for us "in those days and in this time." Therefore, we bless "To kindle the Ner of Hanukkah," so that by the mitzvah of lighting, we may merit to enjoy the lights of these unifications.
This secret is hinted at in Parashat Miketz, in the verse "And Pharaoh dreamed (Cholem)" (Genesis 41:1). The word Cholem has three permutations: Cholem (Dream), Melach (Salt), Lechem (Bread).
Pharaoh is the Klipah corresponding to the Neck (Oref - letters of Paro)[2]. He knew he had a hold on the "neck" of holiness, preventing the light from spreading from the Head to the Body (Israel).
Cholem: The vowel point Cholem is above the letters (Head).
Lechem: The vowel Melapum (Shuruk/Vav with a dot) is inside the letters (Inner).
Melach: The vowel Chirik is below the letters (End).Pharaoh "dreamed" (Cholem)—meaning he held onto the aspect of Cholem (Head alone) and prevented the other two unifications from spreading. Until Joseph the Righteous came and broke Pharaoh's shell (as "Joseph is the provider/breaker" - Gen 42:6), completing the two unifications in the secret of "Covenant of Salt" (Brit Melach - Yesod/Chirik) and "Bread" (Lechem - Melapum).
Alternatively, it can be said:
Hanukkah = Chanu-Kah (Rested-25). The secret of 25 is the 25 letters of the Unification in the verse "Shema Yisrael YHWH Eloheinu YHWH Echad" (Deuteronomy 6:4).
After the Greeks told the Hasmoneans "Write on the horn of an ox that you have no portion in the God of Israel," they were filled with zeal and fought with swords.
This is the secret of what Abraham said to his young men: "Stay here (Po) with the donkey (Chamor)" (Genesis 22:5)—referring to people who are like a donkey (Chamor - attached to Chomer/Materiality). "But I and the lad will go yonder (Ad Koh - until 25)."
This refers to the Binding of Isaac—sacrificing oneself (Mesirut Nefesh) for the 25 letters of the Shema. Regarding this, the Sages said (Berachot 5a): "Whoever recites the Shema is as if he holds a double-edged sword in his hand." The Zohar explains that the letter Yud is the tip of the sword, Vav is the body, and the two Hes are the two edges[3].
Alternatively, it can be said:
The famous question of the Beit Yosef is: Why do we light for eight days? Since there was enough oil for the first day, the miracle only happened for seven days.
One can answer based on the hint in the word Hanukkah, as written in the Abudarham: Hanukkah is an acronym for "Chet Nerot Ve-Halacha Ke-Beit Hillel" (Eight Candles and the Halacha follows Beit Hillel).
This refers to the dispute between Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai (Shabbat 21b):
Beit Hillel: "Ascending and adding"—light one on the first day, up to eight on the last (because we increase in holiness).
Beit Shammai: Light eight on the first day and decrease each day (like the bulls of Sukkot).
If we lit only seven candles [to commemorate only 7 days of miracle], then on the fourth night, there would be no distinction between Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai (both would light 4). Therefore, we light eight days, so that on every single day, the rule of "Ascending in holiness" (Beit Hillel) is distinct and maintained.
Perhaps we can say that each follows their general methodology, as seen in the story of the convert who wanted to learn the Torah "on one foot" (Shabbat 31a):
Hillel said: "What is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbor... go and learn." Meaning, start with "Love your neighbor as yourself" (the foundation), and then add and complete the rest (Ascending).
Shammai pushed him away with a builder's cubit. Meaning, he told him: "We have a complete building of Torah and Mitzvot; you cannot receive it on one foot. You must accept everything first." (Decreasing from the whole).
[1] The candle is the soul, and the light of Wisdom is the life-force.
[2] Sha'ar HaKavanot, Pesach, Discourse 1.
[3] Tikunei Zohar 21: The sword in its sheath is the unification of YHWH and Adonai.