Articles & study materials — Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein
Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Festivals
Sukkot
It is written in the Holy Zohar (Pinchas, section 815) and other holy books that the word Sukkah contains the two Divine Names: YHWH (Havayah) and Adonai.
YHWH (יהו"ה) has the numerical value (Gematria) of 26.
Adonai (אדנ"י) has the numerical value of 65.
Together (26 + 65) they equal 91, which is exactly the numerical value of Sukkah (סוכה = 60+6+20+5 = 91).
This helps us understand the dispute between Rabbi Eliezer and Rabbi Akiva in Tractate Sukkah (11b):
Rabbi Eliezer says: "The Sukkots were Clouds of Glory."
Rabbi Akiva says: "They made themselves actual booths (Sukkot Mamash)."
Seemingly, Rabbi Akiva's opinion is difficult: If we are commemorating simple physical booths and not a miracle, what kind of holiday is this?
The explanation is that these two Names (YHWH and Adonai) encompass the entire matter of Divine Service: Faith (Emunah) and Knowledge (Yedia).
Faith (Clouds of Glory): The Sukkah is called the "Shadow of Faith" (Tzila de-Meheimenuta). This corresponds to Rabbi Eliezer's view of "Clouds of Glory"—the aspect of Faith, where Moses "hid his face" (Exodus 3:6). However, a Sukkah that is too thick (where stars cannot be seen) is invalid[1]. We must leave room for the stars to be seen, representing the lights of God shining into the Sukkah.
Knowledge (Actual Booths): This is the secret of Rabbi Akiva's "Actual Booths." As the Sages said (Megillah 14a) regarding Sarah (Yiscah): "Why was she called Yiscah? Because she gazed (Sokhah) with Divine Spirit." This implies looking, seeing, and attainment (Hassaga). This is the aspect of "Actual Booths" (tangible attainment).
In the service of God, we need both ways; they are not contradictory, but rather one complements the other[2].
This is the unification of the two Names:
YHWH is the secret of Chesed (Mercy) and the Right Line.
Adonai is the secret of the Left Line.
The combination of both (YAHDVNHY - 91 - Sukkah) is the secret of the Middle Line.
Just as water (Right) and fire (Left) contradict, the Middle Line unites them. Sukkah unites Faith (Right/Clouds) and Knowledge (Left/Vision).
Alternatively, it can be said:
Sukkah (91) is numerically equivalent to Amen (91), representing the unification of YHWH (26) and Adonai (65).
After the victory of the High Holy Days (Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur)—where we confessed "We have turned away... and it was not worth it for us" (meaning we did not have equality/balance between the lines)—we now merit the lights of forgiveness and atonement.
This atonement is the secret of Equivalence between the two lines achieved by the Middle Line.
Therefore, on Sukkot, we take the Lulav and Etrog in our hands as the "Signs of Victory" (Simanim), as written in the Zohar (Vayechi, section 228): "He who wins the judgment holds the King's signs in his hands."
[1] Note: Halachically, a thick Sukkah is valid post-facto, but ideally, stars should be visible (Sukkah 22b).
[2] See Parashat Korach above regarding the balance of Faith and Knowledge.
[3] This concept appears also in Igrot HaSulam, Letter 5.