Writings of Baal HaSulam / Letters / Letter 70
From the year 5693 (1933) — To M. L. of Petah Tikva
Text of the question:
Behold... I do not object, and on the contrary, would that the two hundred thousand souls in the land cared for nothing else than for his good... needs. Yet... if... the essence of the Torah is to care for people and nothing more, why do all of Torah and the authors, the Talmud and the Poskim (decisors), almost not speak of this at all? Have they all abandoned the essence and engaged only in the trivial? In my opinion, all his words on this matter contradict the entire accepted religion in Israel as it has spread among us, and in my opinion the power of this sermon is a new construction and a new system that he invented of his own mind.
I wrote, of course, only my opinion.
M. L. of Petah Tikva
Response:
It appears you did not study my words with sufficient care, for I wrote only that there was a conditional requirement from the very beginning of the reception of the Torah. However, afterward, from the time of the making of the calf, the bundle was undone, for wars took place, and the sons of Levi killed three thousand men by the word of the Lord, and afterward the complaints against Moses and Aaron and the spies. Naturally, all these did not add love and unity—and afterward, upon entering the Land, this did not quiet down either, and therefore there was not even a place to expect anyone to fulfill this primary commandment. However, so that the Torah would not be forgotten from Israel, they began to engage in the other commandments even though they left aside the essence, because they had no other choice.
And perhaps to this the Sages directed their intent when they asked regarding the destruction of the Second Temple, where there was no idolatry and they were proficient in the Torah—what was the reason it was destroyed? And they said: on account of causeless hatred (Sinat Hinam). It may be that the intention is that they could not engage in the primary construction of the Torah, which is "Love your neighbor as yourself" (Leviticus 19:18).