Rabbi Binyamin Sinkovsky / Holidays and Festivals / Shavuot
The Innovation of Moses Giving the Torah: Drawing it Down Even to "Lo Lishma" (Not for Its Own Sake)
(Talk from Shavuot 5713 / 1953)
Regarding the Giving of the Torah: Why specifically on Shavuot? What is the innovation here? Did not the Patriarchs and the righteous already keep it before Shavuot? Thus, the giving of the Torah had already occurred! For the Torah is eternal, and since it is eternal, the moment the Holy One, Blessed be He, thought to give it to Israel, the giving was established. So what is the innovation of Shavuot?
Rather, Moses our Teacher, peace be upon him, drew the Torah down to the level of "Lo Lishma" (Not for its own sake). The eternal giving is in the aspect of "Lishma" (For its own sake)—in the World of Atzilut (Emanation). But it was impossible to reach it while in a state of Lo Lishma.
This is the innovation of Moses our Teacher: he drew it down all the way to Lo Lishma. This is the essence of the Giving of the Torah on Shavuot: even someone who engages in it with an invalid intention, only for himself, not to bestow, and not to bring contentment to his Maker—even he can grasp it!
This is the innovation of Moses—that he drew it down to each and every individual of Israel, even in the state of Lo Lishma. And if one engages in it, over time he will be able to grasp the rope of the spiritual degrees, and "the Light within it will reform him" (bring him back to the good). He can attain according to his exertion in it, even though it was Lo Lishma at first.
This is the greatness of Moses' deed—he drew it down "before the eyes of all Israel," meaning to the absolute end of the possibility of Lo Lishma, so that not even one of Israel would be lost. For the "Faithful Shepherd" (Moses) cared for everyone until the end of generations.
Thus, Moses did the greatest work for everyone during the Giving of the Torah on Shavuot. He himself accomplished what all of Israel must do together throughout all generations. Therefore, Moses is equivalent to all of Israel. He made the "preparation" for each and every one.
From this we learn: "The Light within it reforms him." And from this we learn: One can study Torah in any manner, and one should not disdain Lo Lishma, because even in Lo Lishma lies the preparation to reach Lishma.
This is the work of the righteous in every generation: to actualize this preparation and not waste it, some less and some more. Therefore, anyone can be like Moses, because the power of his preparation is present from beginning to end, "before the eyes of all Israel." In one's work, one only needs to recognize Moses' preparation; if one merits to recognize it, his work is desired and bears fruit.
The Patriarchs and the Torah of Atzilut:
One must know with absolute clarity: The Torah at Mount Sinai, which Moses drew down for us (encompassing all 600,000 souls of Israel), is the aspect of the World of Beriah (Creation), meaning Lo Lishma.
For Lishma is in Atzilut, where there is absolute adhesion (Dvekut) only for completely righteous individuals who cleave to God with the ultimate adhesion, like the holy Patriarchs. And these absolute righteous ones do not need gifts, for by their own power they reached what they reached. In their immense adhesion, they became one with the Torah—meaning the Holy One, Blessed be He, Israel, and the Torah are one. They are in Atzilut, and therefore they could keep the Torah before Mount Sinai. Not only could they keep it, but they were literally the Torah itself!
Therefore, it is no wonder that Abraham kept the entire Torah, even the Rabbinic enactments (Eruv Tavshilin). Had he not, he could not have been Abraham our Father, who is one with the Torah. He was compelled to keep the entire Torah, because otherwise he would be flawed, Heaven forbid, lacking the perfection of the Torah of Atzilut; for Lishma is perfection.
The Mystery of Circumcision (Milah):
Why, then, did he not keep the Mitzvah of Circumcision (Milah) on his own, but only through a command from the Holy One, Blessed be He?
Because the Mitzvah of Milah is so great, [He explained in Yiddish: "You cannot trust the owner of the property with it (Tzimtzum Bet / the second restriction), only the parents (Tzimtzum Aleph)"]. Because Abraham our Father, from his own aspect, was entirely Right (Chesed/Mercy). Before the circumcision—there is no Left in that Ancient One. Since the age of three, Abraham recognized his Creator, which correlates to the level of Ta'amim de S"G (pure bestowal) where Milah does not apply. For Milah begins from Tzimtzum Bet (the second restriction, which introduces judgments).
The fact that he did not keep the Mitzvah of Milah on his own, but only through a command from God, means that the word of God performed the action! "He spoke, and it was." As the Sages said: "He found himself circumcised," meaning the command itself circumcised him.
This is also the reason why the Mitzvah of Milah is everywhere written in the passive voice (Nifal): "He shall be circumcised" (Yimol), "And you shall be circumcised" (u'Nemaltem). Therefore, Abraham our Father, who was the first to be circumcised, the first "owner," his circumcision was also in the name of the "parents" (from Above). For this reason, it was impossible for him to fulfill the Mitzvah of Milah on his own.
Thus it is written in the Torah: "On that very day, Abraham was circumcised (Nimol)"—it does not say he "circumcised" (active).
Therefore, Milah is great, as it began with "And God appeared to Abraham... and Abraham fell on his face... God said, As for Me, behold, My covenant is with you." Here the act of circumcision took place. From "Abraham fell on his face"—meaning the lights of S"G descended below the Tabur (navel), the circumcision was established. Malchut ascended to Binah, both intertwining. It is considered that the act of circumcision is through the name Elokim—Malchut of Tzimtzum Aleph, and the Covenant (Brit) is Tzimtzum Bet.