Conversations with Baal HaSulam
Topic: On "Greater is the One Who is Commanded and Does" Holy Shabbat, Parashat Ki Teitzei, 5710 (1950)
He dealt with the matter of "Commanded and Does" (Metzuveh VeOseh), and said: The People of Israel in Egypt were in the aspect of "Not commanded but doing." This was also the opinion of Rabbi Yosef (Kiddushin 31a). They said: "We remember the fish, which we ate in Egypt for free (Chinam)"—meaning, free from commandments, for they were not commanded; [they acted] without coercion and without force. As is known, it is easier to do something of one's own will.
This is the meaning of their saying: "We remember... the cucumbers (Kishuim)"—from the language of Questions/Difficulties (Kushiot); "the watermelons (Avtichim)"—from the language of Security/Assurance (Bitachon). Since it was "for free"—free from commandments—it seemed more important to them, and they gave a reason (Ta'am) for the commandments on their own. And so Rabbi Yosef thought.
Then the Sages came and said: "Greater is the one who is commanded and does." Without questions and examinations, and without giving a reason, but only "The King's Command" do we fulfill, without any sophistications (Hitchakmuyot) or debates, but with Simple Faith (Emunah Peshuta), like that [story] in Midrash Rabbah about engraving within a beam. Then, one merits that the Holy One, Blessed be He, Himself reveals the reason (Ta'am) of the commandment. Then one begins to feel how good, beneficial, and beautiful it is when one merits that the Holy One, Blessed be He, Himself reveals [it]. And then, one does not want any [intellectual] reason, but specifically—without any reason—which is the most precious reason/taste of all.
This creates the Bond (Kesher) between the Holy One, Blessed be He, and the doer of the commandments. And the more commandments one fulfills, the more bonds are made; and when there are more bonds, there is a tighter connection. This is in the aspect of the "Bundle of Life" (Tzror HaChaim)—Tzrora de-Le'ila (The Supernal Bundle) in which all life depends.
But he who is "Not commanded and does"—meaning, he gives a reason of his own, from his own intellect—the Holy One, Blessed be He, has nothing to do with him; for he already has his own reason, and he has lost the Bond. This is why they said: "Greater is the one who is commanded and does."
Here, I wanted to say my own opinion regarding the reason—why is the one who is commanded greater than the one who is not commanded? I said: "Because the one commanded has an Evil Inclination (Yetzer Hara) [resisting him]." The Rabbi rebuked me firmly: "I want to lift you up above, and you pull down?!" And he said: "Is it written 'And God saw the Darkness that it was good'? Is it not written: 'And God saw the Light that it was good'? The meaning is—that the horse is secondary to the rider. For we eat from the King's table, and we are but a Chariot for Him, and He leads us according to His will."