ASHLAG ARCHIVE
EnglishעבריתРусскийEspañol

Topic: "Service is Greater than Study"

Rabbi Binyamin Sinkovsky

Supplied text and translations. Original source files are available below; French translations are retained in the original downloads.

Source files
Text size

Conversations with Baal HaSulam

Topic: "Service is Greater than Study"

Sunday, Parashat Bereshit, 5708 (1947)

Regarding the Zohar and the commentary he writes and that we study, he said that those who engage in collecting money for the printing of his Zohar—this [act] is greater than study. He explained this with the adage: "Greater is the service of [Torah] than the study thereof."

For the external intellect (Sechel Chitzoni), which clothes the Torah studies [done] at the table, dissipates ninety-nine percent of the Light of the Torah from it. And even the little that remains is ineffective for what is needed, because the role of the external intellect is the exact opposite of what is required in the contemplation of Torah for the service of the Creator. Therefore, the Service (Shimush) of Torah scholars is infinitely greater than their study, for then nothing is lost; everything is transmitted to the student without any waste. This corresponds to the matter of collecting money for printing the Zohar, which is exactly the same as Shimush (Service), Bitul (Self-nullification), and Dvekut (Adhesion).

This is the reason why the Oral Torah (Torah Shebe'al Peh) was given—for it is entirely acquired "Mouth to Mouth" (Peh el Peh) and not "Mouth to Ear." Otherwise, there would be no need for the Oral Torah, and the Written Torah would suffice! The entire virtue of Israel is that they did not ask for the reason and logic of the Torah as the nations of the world did, and [thus] did not receive it. Had they asked like them, they would not have received it; and had they asked "What is written in it?", they could not have received it. Rather, they preceded "We will do" (Na'aseh) to "We will hear" (Nishma)—without reason, without question, [with] pure faith in the desire of the Creator, that He is all good, His deeds are good, and His intention is favorable; He is righteous and upright, with no injustice.

Here, Rabbi Baruch asked: "And truly, from where did this faith come to them? Why did they not ask?"

He replied immediately: "From the Fathers (Avot), whose seed we are."

The importance of printing the Zohar lies in this: that surely, masters of spiritual degrees will be able to delve into it, deepen their understanding, and learn the Zohar "Mouth to Mouth."

He further told about himself: Before he became known, about thirty years ago, his students received a very great measure (Shiur) from him. At that time, he was not known through his books, only through the faith in him that he had the ability to give everything. Therefore, they took from him a large portion, a very great measure. But now that he has already become famous through his books, and everyone knows the virtue of his greatness in the study of Kabbalah through his books, the faith has been flawed to a certain extent; therefore, it is impossible to take from him as in the previous lessons.

He also said that every illumination that comes from Above into the hands of man becomes restricted and corrupted—es vert tseriben [it crumbles], it becomes a dry and ruined reality. That is the reason there is no Inner Light (Ohr Pnimi) without Surrounding Light (Ohr Makif). This [Surrounding Light] remains with the Almighty and does not terminate (Kalah). Therefore, the Creator does not give the Light completely, but leaves the Essence of the Light with Himself, and this is His unique virtue in the Wisdom of the Creator.

Here, I, the humble one, asked: "Is it not the destiny of the Surrounding Light to become Inner Light!?"

He answered: "But the first, root Surrounding Light remains with the Holy One, Blessed be He. There is no absence in spirituality; but if this were to come to the created being, there would indeed be absence."

This is the interpretation of "For I give you good doctrine (Lekach)" and also "My doctrine (Likchi) shall drop as the rain"—from the language of "taking" (Lakah), Nemehin in foreign tongue (taking/grasping). Therefore, He calls it Lekach, implying taking, because when the Light of Torah comes to us, it crumbles—it becomes terminated (Kalah) within us. And since its Root always remains whole in the aspect of Makif (Surrounding), we therefore always have [new] work to return and draw the Light anew.

This is solely the virtue of Israel, "Who has chosen us from all the peoples," "You have chosen us from all the peoples, loved us, and exalted us above all tongues, and sanctified us with Your commandments, and Your great and holy Name You have proclaimed upon us." Meaning, only within the Nation of Israel is this virtue of the Oral Torah discerned, which means "Mouth to Mouth" and not "Mouth to Ear." This is also the greatness of Israel and their superiority over all nations.

This is also the interpretation of the Sages' statement: The Holy One, Blessed be He, went around to all the nations and offered them the Torah before giving it to Israel. But they immediately asked, "What is written in it?" They wanted everything ready-made, without work, without effort, without preparation of purity and holiness, without faith in the infinity of attainment; they only wanted everything ready in writing. This is the intention of their saying: "What is written in it?"

But "Israel," the children of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, believers sons of believers, did not ask "What is written in it." On the contrary, they preceded "We will do" to "We will hear"—without question, without reason, without investigation (from the aspect of external intellect), but all with pure faith, refined faith in the Omnipotence of the Holy One, Blessed be He—that He is unlimited and infinite. Therefore, His gifts are also infinite, and one cannot ask "What is written in it." Rather, they preceded "We will do" to "We will hear," which means the negation of natural power and tangible understanding of the external intellect—which only accepts what the external intellect agrees to and limits it according to its natural senses. This is the complete opposite of faith and Dvekut (Adhesion)—[which is] the expansion of the pure, holy intellect into infinity by means of pure faith, by means of adhesion to Him, Blessed be He.

And this is possible only through the unique virtue that exists only in the Nation of Israel, the Chosen People—"You have chosen us, sanctified us, and desired us"—for otherwise, it is impossible to reach the Oral Torah which Israel merited.