Conversations with Baal HaSulam
Two Klipot: Knowledge and Heresy (Yediah ve-Kefirah) Talk after the lesson, Monday, Parashat Bo, Rosh Chodesh Shevat, 5712 (1952) – Zohar Vayikra
Regarding the path of Divine Service (Avdut), it should be noted that Dinim de-Nukva (Female Judgments) correspond to the Klipah of Heresy (Kefirah), and Dinim de-Dechura (Male Judgments) correspond to the Klipah of Knowledge (Yediah).
The question arises: How is it possible for a righteous person (Tzadik) who walks in the way of God to have foreign thoughts and heresy, Heaven forbid? This is truly incomprehensible. Complete Faith (Emunah Shlemah) is the opposite of Knowledge and in total contradiction to it. So, if he is always in Faith, how is Heresy possible? The explanation is: He who is truly in Complete Faith always cannot fall into heresy. Rather, what happens? The Holy One, Blessed be He, wishes to bestow upon the man of Faith more and more Mochin (Consciousness), Da'at (Knowledge), Faith, and Wisdom. What does He do? If he remains always in Faith at one level, he will not be able to ascend! So what does He do? He created an "Opposite" (Le'umat). This "Opposite" sneaks up on the believer in "Wholeheartedness"—in addition to Faith, it gives him Knowledge (Yediah). The man of Complete Faith thinks to himself: "What harm can additional knowledge do to my Faith?" So he strives to acquire Knowledge, which is the aspect of Dinim de-Dechura from the point of Shuruk, and they are from the aspect of the Left Klipah.
Since the Left Klipah acquires a place in the man of Faith through the Knowledge it gives him, by this he also gives place and a foothold to the Second Klipah of the Right, which is the aspect of Heresy and foreign thoughts. Thus, both Klipot settle within him. Until the believer begins to feel heresy within himself and wonders: "How is heresy possible in me, who am always in pure Faith?" After all, Faith is in complete opposition to Knowledge, and how much more so to Heresy.
But as we explained: The Holy One, Blessed be He, wishes to benefit His believers and increase their Torah and Wisdom so they do not remain in a frozen state, but always go "from strength to strength." He helps them via the "Opposite"—namely, Dinim de-Nukva and Dinim de-Dechura, both of which are Klipot:
Dinim de-Nukva are the Right Klipah coming from Deficiency (Chisaron), and the Klipah always grabs hold in the place of deficiency; this brings about Heresy.
But how can this Klipah, whose essence is heresy, acquire a resting place and a grip in a man of pure Faith? After all, Faith always justifies everything and allows no deviation from God's service, even if it contradicts external logic completely! How is heresy and foreign thought relevant there?
Rather, as we said: First, he was grasped by Knowledge—where the Left Klipah adds to his Faith, which seemingly does not disturb Faith but even strengthens it through added knowledge. But since Knowledge—which is the Left Klipah, Dinim de-Dechura—acquires a place in the believer, afterwards this Klipah serves the Right Klipah of Heresy as well. And since the Left Klipah already exists within him unknowingly, this enables the entry of the Right Klipah of Heresy. Only afterwards does the Holy One, Blessed be He, help the man of Faith, and he is liberated from both Klipot together through corrections and repentance, and ascends and strengthens in Faith.
During this conversation, when I began to complain to him that after I left my line and grasped his advice, I felt that I fell until I could barely grasp the lesson in the Holy Zohar—whereas last week I was so inflamed that everything seemed to me clear as the sun (Barah KaChamah), and today everything is covered in fog—he said to me: "I knew it would be so. Because a servant of God is forbidden to stand in the middle of the road. Even when es sheint im gut [it shines well for him], s'sheint dir, du host shoin alts, un vos vaiter? Un vos vaiter? [Even if the Good Light shines for you, and it shines for you, and you already have everything—what next? And what next?]"
He wanted to emphasize by this that any satisfaction (Histapkut) with a level is not from Holiness. For the entire matter of Service and Torah in the way of God is only the goal to serve more and cling to Him. In his holy language: "Un vos vaiter? Der inyan vos du host durchgemacht hostu B"H gut gehoiben... aber vos vaiter? Du vilst shoin do blaiben shtain ch"v... s'iz nishto kein gashmiyus un ruchniyus, s'iz nor do Kabbalah un Hashpa'ah!" [And what next? The matter you went through, you elevated well, thank God, and you withstood the test, and you have a high level. But what next? Do you want to remain in that state, Heaven forbid? You surely do not want to remain standing but to continue forward. Therefore, you must go out of your state, even though you feel good, and it shines so well for you. But the main thing is to be for Bestowal, entirely to Bestow. And if you remain standing, you are, Heaven forbid, a Receiver. It makes no difference whether it is Corporeality (Gashmiut) or Spirituality (Ruchniut). If you are for Bestowal, your Corporeality is also Spirituality. If you are, Heaven forbid, a Receiver, then your Spirituality is also Corporeality! There is no Corporeality and Spirituality; there is only Reception and Bestowal! The entire complicated and complex matter is expressed in two words: Reception and Bestowal. And this is the entire Work and Service, and there is nothing more. If you are a Bestower, then everything is Spirituality; everything the Creator created for His glory, to use for servitude.]
"In dem matzav falen a sach avek..." [In this state, many fall and collapse. And one must guard oneself very much, and great mercy is needed. Because here you are in a difficult situation—in a situation where, thank God, you attained Divine attainments, because it is good, and it shines so clearly, and one begins to receive satisfaction, and there is no desire to leave this state and continue further to attain more than this. And if one remains standing, Heaven forbid, then what will become of you further?... After all, you stand before the Holy One, Blessed be He, and you stand before the Infinite (Ein Sof). So how can you remain standing in the middle? And if you remain standing, then there, where you remained standing—there the Creator is not found, because the Blessed Creator is Infinite. It is impossible to remain standing; one must go further, continue with enthusiasm...]