Baal HaSulam The Greatness of the Wisdom of Kabbalah and the Smallness of Philosophy From the book Likutim B, published by the Ateret Shlomo Institute
Body of the Article:
A' 47. The wisdom of Kabbalah begins where the wisdom of philosophy ends:
The anger of the authors over the simple publication of "The whole earth is full of His glory" brought in Hasidic books: (Isaiah 6:3) Regarding what is written in a certain book, that the GRA (Vilna Gaon), of blessed memory, was deeply offended by a Hasidic book which wrote that the Creator is enclothed in all Inanimate, Vegetative, Animate, and Speaking [levels of nature], and he said that this falls under "those who despise the Lord," etc. Let his honor remain in its place, but I say that this is an individual opinion and the attainment of his particular soul. However, in the Zohar, the Tikkunim, and the Sefer Yetzirah, it is brought that the light of His holiness, blessed be He, is indeed enclothed in all the Inanimate, Vegetative, Animate, and Speaking. And whoever the Creator has given eyes to see the root point of the 32 Paths of Wisdom, will see how His Light, blessed be He, is enclothed even in the most despicable things in the eyes of man. "For man looks at the outward appearance, but the Lord looks at the heart" (1 Samuel 16:7). If the Creator prepared for us vessels of perception that perceive things as despicable and things as honorable, there is no necessity to say that it is so in His own eyes, blessed be He. For this discernment is given only for the preservation of the body, such that things beneficial to us we perceive as honorable, and those that harm us—as despicable. This is valid only in our valuation; because we are harmed by them, we despise them. But this does not apply to the Creator, Heaven forbid, for these boundaries do not serve Him at all, and thus everything is equal before Him, the honorable as the despicable. And this is the secret of the author of the Shir HaYihud: "No filth can defile You, consuming fire cannot burn You" (Yom Kippur Eve), and this is simple.
However, regarding the core of the verse "The whole earth is full of His glory" (Isaiah 6:3), which the GRA, of blessed memory, wanted to interpret solely from the perspective of His Providence, blessed be He, and not from the perspective of His enclothement within them—because it seemed to him like corporeality, or because many philosophers also concede to this—this matter must be understood. For in truth, "no thought can grasp Him at all," not only from the perspective of affirmation but also from the perspective of negation. If, for example, we perceive with our intellect that the spiritual does not occupy space, and that a great intellect can be enclothed in a space smaller than the point of a needle, this still offers no proof that the intellect is banished from a large space, occupying only a corner as a tiny point, leaving the rest empty of it. Because the meaning of the spiritual not occupying space is that it is not bound to space, but not that it is forbidden to exist in space and time. On the contrary, if it does not occupy space, it must necessarily be present in all places and at all times, and also outside of them, that is, even in what is completely unperceivable to us. For if you know for certain that He is not present in a corporeal space, you have attained something of His essence under one condition: from the perspective of negation. And this too is a disgrace for limited man, who knows absolutely nothing of the spiritual essence.
The truth is that a person cannot be present in a place where he has no perception according to the preparation of the five senses given to him by the Creator. That which is devoid of space and time is completely empty to him, and this negation is an actual denial of the reality of the spiritual. We cannot compare it to our intellect, which we perceive as such, because it has a connection with imagination and the senses, and therefore it is a reality even though we negate it, because it is grasped by us. This is not the case with the Creator, who is not connected to imagination and the senses; therefore, it is an understanding that denies Him.
[From Your actions we know You:] However, in truth, we do not need to understand the Creator in His essence, and we are not lacking this. It is enough for us to see His actions, as it is written, "From Your actions we know You," meaning from the form of His actions. For even regarding our own essence, we only perceive it through imagination and the senses, which recognize only the form of actions—such as hard, soft, shadows, and the like—which is enough to recognize ourselves and our surroundings. The parable is known: if you lock a boy and a girl in a room so they never come into contact with any human being, nevertheless, when they grow up, they will recognize each other and have children. From here is the proof that the will of the Creator generates yearning, and from yearning, they come to recognition and action. If we attribute this yearning to the essence of the light within the boy and the girl, which is enclothed in them immediately from birth, we are not materializing the force of this yearning at all by saying it occupies space, even though, according to the sense of perception, the yearning fills all the 613 organs and veins of the boy and girl. Thus, the spiritual, on the one hand, does not occupy space at all, and on the other hand, it fills the entire reality of the space.
Similarly, the Creator prepared a force in His creations to yearn for Him, each of the Inanimate, Vegetative, Animate, and Speaking according to its degree. One could say the earth yearns to receive rain, and the tree to draw moisture from the earth, because the Creator implanted this yearning within them. It is understood that this force was already separated, issued, and decreed from His Light and remained in the earth and the tree. On the other hand, one could say that this force of yearning was not yet separated from the Light of the Creator, and intellect dictates this. For who decreed and separated it, and why must it be separated? If to us the tree is very despicable because it lacks knowledge and feeling, to its Maker who created it, it is not despicable at all, for He intentionally made it so.
Furthermore, according to simple logic without deep investigation, His essence, blessed be He, is understood as possessing absolute rest, because that which moves necessarily requires space. Since He does not occupy space, He is necessarily in absolute rest. If so, how can it be said that His Light is capable of movement, meaning materialized in space? This is saying yes and no together. Therefore, you are forced to say that this Light of yearning prepared in the tree and the earth is not separated from His essence, blessed be He, because if it were separated, it would need to move and would be limited in space like us.
A' 48. The Differences between Inanimate, Vegetative, Animate, and Speaking: Thus, it is clarified that His Light, blessed be He, is enclothed in all the Inanimate, Vegetative, Animate, and Speaking, and is not separated from them. What we call "illumination" (He'arah) is due to the shared relationship it has with the tree or the earth. This illumination is a form of action in our intellectual preparation {even though we have no true perception of the essence of the illumination, following the premise that we have no perception of any essence and primary matter }. Accordingly, we must also make distinctions in His illumination, namely according to the shared relationship within the vessel of enclothement. In the Inanimate, it is small and inferior to all, because nothing separated to move it from a private perspective, and all inanimate objects share a collective form. Added to this is the Vegetative, where each particular item already has a specific movement according to its will to receive, but without feeling. That is, a general force is placed upon each type of vegetation to move them thus, but without a unique private force for each tree alone. It is also bound to the inanimate without entirely free movement. Added to this is the Animate, where each particular item already has a unique movement of its own, even the smallest detail, and is completely detached from the inanimate. Added to this is the Speaking (Human), who has an awareness of his existence and the existence of his environment, and the speculative intellectual power that joins them to perceive one another. Each individual has his own, has his generation's, and inherits from all past generations, growing infinitely.
(Note: To understand this wisdom, one must find the common denominator where there is no difference from the upper to the lower).
[The Psychologists:] Psychologists have already stated that an infant first feels those in its environment, and only later feels its own self. They noted accurately that initially, the infant refers to itself in the third person, not saying "I want," but saying about itself "he wants," or calling itself by its name. The reason for this—although seemingly it should have felt itself first—is exactly what we have spoken: the senses and imagination of any person do not perceive essence, but only the form of actions. Therefore, the actions of its environment precede the feeling of its own actions.
Even adults only know of themselves the form of their own actions. The all-encompassing whole is called "feeling," similar to the sense of touch, whereby one feels in their existence that they are alive, moving, and warm. In the same way, one feels their friends, that they feel themselves alive, warm, and moving. This is the entire internality of one's recognition of others. From this feeling, all various actions branch out: intellectual, emotional, and practical. However, we have absolutely no perception of the essence of life, ours or our friends'. From this, philosophers found room to investigate what the essence of man is, and they became lost in endless waters.
In truth, all the upper and lower worlds, the honored and the despised, all emerged from a single thought, as it were, which is to do good to His creations—as comes to us from Kabbalah and prophecy, not from philosophy. All this goodness that He intended for us, we call by the name of His Light, which is not, Heaven forbid, separated from His essence. Rather, to soothe the ear and speak according to our perception regarding the shared relationship between lights and vessels—since we must perceive everything only in forms of actions—we are compelled to define the form of action from His essence by the name "illumination" (He'arah). Meaning, as it was, it emerged from a state of absolute rest and came into movement, within that shared relationship in the vessel.
Thus, there is no concept more guarded against any form of materialization than the definition of an illumination expanding from His essence, blessed be He. This was prepared for our perception both in the upper and lower realms, not through thoughts like our thoughts which achieve nothing, and certainly not through actions or similar limited corporeal concepts, but an expanding illumination, which at its end makes a vessel to enclothe within. And even this we name according to our perception, as we only perceive a moving form. But regarding the Creator, this form does not move; rather, even the expanding illumination is in His own state, inseparable from Him and unmoving, and is literally like His essence.
A' 49. The whole earth is full of His glory: Therefore, those sages who specifically wanted to explain the verse "The whole earth is full of His glory" (Isaiah 6:3) in terms of His Providence, blessed be He, actually create an infinitely greater materialization than the explanation of the Kabbalists, which is that He enclothes Himself in them, and guides them by enclothing in them. This is a much more spiritual and truer definition within the capability of our attained expression: that He supervises His creations by enclothing within them themselves, and nothing is despicable, Heaven forbid, before His eyes.
According to this, we must necessarily differentiate between the upper and lower worlds, and between the righteous who are of benefit and the wicked who destroy the world, since you say that "the whole earth is full of His glory," and He enclothes equally in all. In general, we must understand that for Him it is so, but not for us. For us, there are degrees of good and corresponding evil and harm, by way of reward and punishment. But for Him, there is only private providence within every soul.
A' 50. I am the Lord who dwells... in the midst of their uncleanness: To understand this, we must thoroughly understand this law: whatever does not enter a person's feeling is considered by him as something entirely non-existent, which does not affect him for good or bad, and does not touch him. Therefore, even though His Light is enclothed in the inanimate as it is in the human, nonetheless, regarding the inanimate itself, it is not enclothed at all, because it does not feel Him. Similarly, even though His Light is also enclothed in sinners, as it is written, "I am the Lord who dwells with them in the midst of their uncleanness" (Leviticus 16:16), nevertheless, regarding themselves, this is considered as if He is not in reality at all, since they do not feel Him so. But the righteous, to whom a special love is made known [Torah Or: "Special love is made known to them" (Avot 3:14)], that the Creator is enclothed within them and they feel Him so—this is considered for them a true reality, just like other things in corporeal reality are for the rest of creation.
A' 51. What is enclothement? According to this, you will easily understand the difference between the upper and lower worlds. The upper ones feel His enclothement to a very great measure, and every world smaller than its counterpart is small only in the feeling of the reality of the enclothement, even though the reality in essence does not change at all. This continues until, in the lower realms, the feeling is completely hidden and is considered, according to their valuation, as not enclothed in them at all. And this is the absolute truth as well, for whatever is not felt is not in reality. In a way that the simple understanding of enclothement is the feeling of His enclothement, and not the essence of the enclothement, which does not change at all.
A' 52. Just as there is no difference from upper to lower in the essence of the enclothement, so there is no difference in the vessel of reception: Who causes these differences? Know that it is the vessel itself, for the vessel is the "will to receive," and by this the Inanimate, Vegetative, Animate, and Speaking and all their details differ. The same applies in all the upper worlds, because regarding the vessel of reception, there is also no difference from upper to lower. Just as there is no difference in the essence of the enclothement, rather all the clarity of this vessel among the upper ones is commensurate with the Equivalence of Form to the Emanator, which is the "will to bestow."