ASHLAG ARCHIVE
EnglishעבריתРусскийEspañol
Back to Library

Critique of World Peace

Baal HaSulam

The supplied English translation is an excerpt and ends with an ellipsis. The other language versions contain additional sections.

Original source files

Translations beyond the four archive languages are available in the original files.

Text size

"Mercy and truth are met together; righteousness and peace have kissed each other. Truth shall spring out of the earth; and righteousness shall look down from heaven. Yea, the Lord shall give that which is good; and our land shall yield her increase." (Psalms 85:10-12)

There is Nothing Evil or Superfluous in Creation – It is Merely Something That Has Not Completed Its Development

Everything that exists in reality, whether good or bad, and even the most evil and harmful things in the world, has a right to exist. To such an extent that we are forbidden to destroy it or eradicate it completely from the world; rather, our duty is only to correct it and reform it. For by merely observing the work of creation before us, it is enough for us to determine the immense perfection of its Maker. Therefore, we must understand and be careful not to cast doubt on any detail of creation, to say that it is superfluous and unnecessary, as this would be tantamount to slandering its Maker, God forbid.

Indeed, it is known to all that the Creator, blessed be He, did not complete creation at the time He created it. We see this in every corner of the reality before us, both in general and in particular, that it is subject to laws of gradual development, starting from absence until the completion of its growth. For this reason, if, for example, we taste a bitter flavor in a fruit at the beginning of its growth, we do not consider this a flaw or defect in the fruit, because we all know the reason: the fruit has simply not yet completed its developmental process to the end. This is the case with the rest of the details of reality. If we perceive an aspect of evil or harm in a certain detail, it only testifies about itself that it is still in a transitional state of its developmental process. Under no circumstances should we determine and decide that it is inherently evil, and we should not cast doubt on this detail, for it is not wise to do so.

This is the source of all the weaknesses of the "world reformers" throughout the generations. They view humanity as a machine that is not working properly, which needs fixing—meaning, removing the defective parts and replacing them with corrected ones. Thus, the entire trend of these world reformers is merely to eradicate every evil and harmful thing in the human species.

And the truth is, if the Creator Himself did not stand against them, they certainly would have managed long ago to sift humanity through a sieve, leaving only the good and useful. However, because the Creator meticulously watches over all the details of His creation and does not permit anyone to destroy anything in His domain, but only to restore and transform it for the better (as we stated above), therefore, all reformers of this kind will vanish from the earth, while the evil traits in the world will not vanish. Instead, they wait and count the number of developmental stages they are still required to undergo until they reach their final ripening. At that time, those very evil traits will transform and become good and useful traits, exactly as the Creator planned for them from the beginning. This is similar to a fruit hanging on the branches of a tree, waiting and counting the days and months it must undergo until it completes its ripening, at which point its flavor and sweetness will be revealed to every person.

Two Paths of Development: "In Its Time" and "I Will Hasten It" (The Rule of Heaven and the Rule of Earth)

However, one must know that the aforementioned law of development, which is poured over all of reality and promises to turn every evil into good and useful, operates through the power of the "Rule of Heaven" from above. That is to say, without asking the permission of the people dwelling on earth. In contrast, the Creator gave humanity intellect and dominion, permitting man to take this law of development under his own authority and rule. When he does so, he greatly accelerates this developmental process according to his own will, freely and completely independent of the chains of time.

Thus, there are two authorities operating in these paths of development. One is the "Rule of Heaven," which ensures the transformation of every evil and harmful thing into good and useful. However, this happens "in its due time" (b'ito), in its characteristic heavy and prolonged manner. If the developing entity is a living, feeling creature, it suffers terrible pain and agony while placed under the press of development, which carves its path with great cruelty. Conversely, there is the "Rule of Earth," meaning human beings who have taken the aforementioned laws of development under their own authority. Their power is sufficient to completely free themselves from the chains of time, greatly hastening the end—that is, the final ripening and correction of the matter, which is the end of its development.

This is what our Sages of blessed memory said (Sanhedrin 98a) regarding the final redemption and complete correction of Israel. They explained the verse (Isaiah 60:22), "I the Lord will hasten it in its time": "If they merit - I will hasten it (Achishena); if they do not merit - in its time (B'ito)." They meant that if Israel merits and takes the law of development—which must pass over their bad traits until they turn into good ones—and brings it under their own rule (meaning they set their hearts and minds to correct their bad traits themselves and turn them into good ones), then "I will hasten it." This means they are completely freed from the chains of time, and this end depends henceforth on their own will, according to the abundance of their actions and attention. By doing so, they hasten the end.

But if they do not merit taking the development of their bad traits under their own rule, but leave it under the Rule of Heaven, even then they are guaranteed their final redemption and complete correction. For there is absolute certainty in the Rule of Heaven, which operates according to the law of gradual development, step by step, until it transforms every evil and harmful thing into good and useful, like the fruit on the tree. The end is absolutely certain, but "in its time" (b'ito)—meaning the matter is completely dependent on and bound by the measure of time. Because this gradual development, until it reaches its end, must undergo numerous and various stages, which tend to come with extreme heaviness and profound slowness, taking an enormous amount of time.

Since the developing subjects in this case are living, feeling creatures, they are forced to endure tremendous and terrible suffering in these developmental stages. This is because the driving force within these stages—which pushes man to ascend from a lower stage to a higher one—is nothing but the driving force of suffering and pain that accumulates in the lower stage until it can no longer be tolerated. At that point, they are forced to abandon it and rise to a higher stage. As our Sages said (Sanhedrin 97b): "The Holy One, blessed be He, establishes a king over them whose decrees are as harsh as Haman's, and Israel repents and He brings them back to the good."

Thus, the end guaranteed to come to Israel through the aforementioned law of gradual development is called "In its time" (b'ito), meaning it is bound by the ropes of time. But the end guaranteed to Israel by taking the development of their traits into their own hands is called "I will hasten it" (Achishena), meaning it is completely independent of time.

Good and Evil are Evaluated in Relation to the Benefit or Harm to the Public

Before we delve into the observation of the correction of evil in the human species, we must first establish the value of those abstract terms, "Good and Evil." That is to say, relative to whom do we evaluate a trait or action to define whether it is a good trait and action, or conversely, a bad trait and action?

To understand this, we must clearly know the relative value between the individual and the collective—that is, between the individual and his society, from which the individual lives and is nourished, both materially and spiritually. From tangible reality, we learn that the individual has no right to exist at all if he were isolated to himself without a sufficient public to serve him and help supply his needs. We understand from this that man was originally created to live a social life. Every single individual in society is like a single gear integrated into a machine of many gears. The single gear has no freedom of movement based on its own individuality, but is pulled along with the movement of all the gears in a specific direction, to make the machine fit for its general function. If a malfunction occurs in a gear, the malfunction is not evaluated based on the individuality of the gear itself, but based on its function and service regarding the entire machine. Likewise, we must evaluate the measure of goodness of every single individual within his society not according to his own benefit, but according to his service to the public as a whole. Conversely, we do not evaluate the measure of an individual's evil except by the degree to which he harms the general public, and not according to his own individual value.

These matters are as clear as the sun at noon, both regarding their truth and their goodness. For the collective contains nothing but what is in the individual, and the benefit of the public means the benefit of every single individual within that public. The individual who harms the public ultimately takes his share of that harm. Likewise, the individual who benefits the public takes his share of that benefit, since these individuals are parts of the public, and the public has no added value beyond the sum of the individuals within it. Therefore, one must understand that the public and the individual are one and the same. There is no detriment to the individual due to his great subjugation to the public, for even the freedom of the public and the freedom of the individual are one and the same. Just as they share the good, so they share the freedom. Thus, good traits and bad traits, good actions and bad actions, are evaluated solely in relation to the benefit of the public.

Of course, this applies specifically if all individuals in the public perfectly fulfill their role to the public, and also take their provision exactly as they truly deserve, meaning they do not take their friend's share. However, if a portion of the public does not behave as stated, the result is that not only do they harm the public, but they also harm themselves.

There is no need to elaborate further on something so well-known. We have traced the matter up to this point only to expose the point of vulnerability—the place that demands correction. That is, to show that the world lacks nothing, except that every individual must understand that his well-being depends on the just service of every individual to the public, and the just distribution to every individual from the public. If this were so, we would certainly have a world filled with all good things; we simply need to know how to enjoy it.

The Four Attributes that Have Shaped Human Development Until Today

Having clearly known the measure of good hoped for us in its form and image—namely: A) that all individuals in the public perfectly fulfill their role, each doing what is required of him; and B) that every individual takes his rightful share of provision in a just measure, so that no one touches his friend's share—we must now look at and consider the actual means at our disposal to hasten this goodness and happiness for ourselves.

We find four attributes available to us for this matter: Mercy (Chesed), Truth (Emet), Justice (Tzedek), and Peace (Shalom). All world reformers have utilized these up to this day. Or more correctly, through these four attributes, human evolution (meaning the Rule of Heaven) has paved its gradual path until bringing humanity to its current state.

We have already discussed earlier that it is fitting and better for us to take the law of development into our own hands and under our own authority, because then we will free ourselves from all the suffering that evolutionary history has written for us from now on. Therefore, we will examine and scrutinize these four attributes to clearly know what they have given us up to this day, so that we may know from them what we can still hope they will assist us with in the future.

Life Cannot Be Organized According to Truth

Theoretically, there is certainly no attribute better than Truth. For all the good we defined above—perfect fulfillment of the individual's role to the public and the taking of a just share by each individual—is nothing but a matter of truth. The only flaw is that, in practice, this attribute is not accepted by the public at all. The practical difficulty inherent in this aforementioned truth proves in itself that there is some defect and cause preventing it from being accepted by the public. We must consider what this is.

When you thoroughly examine this truth regarding its practical capacity, you will inevitably find it to be extremely foggy and complicated, impossible for the human eye to grasp. For the truth requires us to equalize all individuals in the public, so that they receive their share according to the measure of their effort, no less and no more. This is the only true basis that cannot be contested, for it is certain that anyone who wishes to enjoy the effort of his fellow goes against logic and this clear truth.

However, how can we clarify this truth in a way that is acceptable to the hearts of all members of the public? For example, if we judge the matter based on visible hourly labor—meaning that everyone in the public works an equal number of hours—this still does not reveal the truth to us at all. On the contrary, there is a blatant lie here due to two factors: First, a physical factor. The natural physical strength for labor is not equal in everyone. You have one person in society who, due to his weakness, exhausts himself in one hour much more than his friend does in two hours or more.

Second, we face a psychological factor. One who is naturally very lazy also exhausts himself in one hour more than his friend does in two hours or more. From the perspective of pure truth, we should not compel one part of society to exhaust themselves for their livelihood more than the other part. Because in practice, the naturally strong and energetic people in society enjoy the labor of others and exploit them maliciously, contrary to the truth, because they exert themselves very little compared to the weak and lazy in society.

Furthermore, if we take into account the natural law of "following the majority" (Exodus 23:2), this kind of truth—basing everything only on visible hourly labor—is utterly unsustainable. The weak and the lazy are always the distinct majority in society, and they will not permit the minority of the energetic and strong to exploit their strength and effort.

Since the basis of effort—which contains the clear truth and the majority of society—cannot be measured or evaluated at all, it follows that the attribute of truth has no practical capacity to absolutely organize the ways of the individual and the public. That is, it cannot definitively satisfy the mind, and it lacks that complete sufficiency required for the organization of life at the end of the world's correction.

Moreover, there is an even greater trouble here. There is no truth more evident than nature itself. And it is natural that every single person feels himself in the Creator's world as an absolute sole ruler, feeling that all others were created only to ease and improve his life, without feeling any obligation on his part to give anything in return.

In simple words, the nature of every person is to exploit the lives of all creatures in the world for his own benefit. Whatever he gives to another, he gives only out of necessity. And even in this necessity where he gives to him, there is still an element of exploitation of the other, but done with great cunning, so that his fellow will not notice and will yield to him willingly.

The reason for this is that every branch's nature is close to its root. Since the soul of man is drawn from the Creator, who is the One and Only and to whom everything belongs, man, drawn from Him, likewise feels that all the creatures of the world must be under his rule and for his private benefit. This is an unbreakable law. The difference only stands out in people's choices. One chooses to exploit people by achieving lowly desires, another by achieving power, and a third by achieving honor. Furthermore, if any of them could achieve it without great effort, they would agree to exploit the world through all of these together—wealth, power, and honor—but one is forced to choose according to his capabilities. This law can be called the "Law of Singularity" within the human heart. No person escapes it; the great according to his greatness, and the small according to his smallness.

This aforementioned Law of Singularity in every person's nature is neither to be condemned nor praised, for it is a natural reality. It has a right to exist like all details of reality, and there is no hope of eradicating it from the world, or even slightly blurring its form, just as there is no hope of eradicating the entire human species from the earth. Therefore, we will not be lying at all if we call this law the "Absolute Truth."

And since this is undoubtedly so, how can we even attempt to satisfy the individual's mind by promising to equalize him with all members of the public? Nothing is further from human nature than this, while the individual's entire aspiration is to rise above the entire public.

Thus, we have clearly shown that there is absolutely no possibility of bringing happy and good arrangements to the life of the individual and the public based on the attribute of Truth in a way that satisfies the mind of every single individual so they grant it their absolute consent, as it must be at the end of correction.

The Weakness of Truth Caused the Division of Society According to the Four Attributes

Now let us take the remaining three attributes: Mercy, Justice, and Peace. On the surface, they were originally created only to serve as supports, to brace the extremely weak attribute of Truth in our world. Know that from here, evolutionary history began to climb its slow and lagging steps in organizing public life.

In theory, all members of society agreed and took upon themselves with full force not to deviate from the Truth even slightly. However, in practice, everyone conducted themselves completely contrary to the agreed Truth. Since then, the lot of all Truth has fallen to the biggest liars, and it is never found with the weak and righteous so that they could even use the Truth to assist themselves, neither in whole nor in part.

Because they could not implement the attribute of Truth in public life, the disadvantaged and oppressed multiplied in society. From this, the attributes of Mercy and Justice sprouted to act within social systems. For the overall survival of society forced the successful among them to support the disadvantaged, so as not to harm society as a whole. Therefore, they acted with them beyond the letter of the law—namely, with Mercy and Charity (Tzedakah/Justice). However, by their nature, such conditions multiply the disadvantaged and oppressed until they are numerous enough to protest against the successful and to cause strife and quarrels. From this, the attribute of Peace emerged and was revealed in the world. Thus, all these attributes—Mercy, Justice, and Peace—were born from the weakness of Truth, which caused society to split into factions. Some grasped Mercy and Charity (meaning giving up their property for others), while others grasped the attribute of Truth (meaning "mine is mine, and yours is yours").

In simpler terms, they can be divided into "Builders" and "Destroyers." The Builders, who desired the construction and benefit of the general public, were therefore frequently forced to give up their property to others. But those who were naturally inclined toward destruction and lawlessness could seize and grasp the attribute of Truth for their private benefit—"mine is mine, and yours is yours." They never wanted to give up even the slightest bit of their share to others, failing to consider that by doing so they endanger the existence of the public, being destroyers by nature.

The Hope for Peace – Lacking Value

After these conditions brought society to immense conflicts, and society as a whole came into a state of danger, peacemakers emerged and revealed themselves in society. They took the assertiveness and power into their hands and renewed social life based on new conditions—truthful in their eyes—that would ensure the existence of society in peace.

However, these peacemakers, who emerge and come after every conflict, naturally come mostly from the "Destroyers"—meaning the seekers of Truth in the sense of "mine is mine, and yours is yours." This is because they are the powerful and bold in society, called the brave-hearted, for they are always ready to risk their own lives and the lives of the entire public if the public does not agree with their views. This is not the case with the Builders in society (the people of Mercy and Charity). Their own lives are precious to them, and the life of the public is also precious to them. They are not willing to risk themselves and the public, placing them in danger to force the public to agree with their views. Therefore, they are always the weak side in society, called cowards and the fearful. It goes without saying that the reckless, brave-hearted always gain the upper hand. Therefore, it is natural that all peacemakers come from the Destroyers, and not from the Builders.

From this, we see how the hope for Peace, which our entire generation eagerly awaits, is devoid of value, both from the perspective of the subject and the object. Regarding the subjects—the peacemakers of our generation and every generation, meaning those holding the power to make peace in the world—they are always made of that human material we call "Destroyers," because they are seekers of Truth, aiming to establish the world on the principle of "mine is mine, and yours is yours." It is natural that such people firmly insist on their views to the point of endangering their lives and the life of the entire public. This always gives them the power to overcome that other human material, the Builders (the seekers of Mercy and Charity, who are willing to yield what is theirs for the benefit of others to save the construction of the world), who are cowards and fearful. Thus, seeking Truth and destroying the world are one and the same; and seeking Mercy and building the world are one and the same. Therefore, there is no hope at all that peace will be built by the Destroyers.

Similarly, the hoped-for Peace is completely lacking value from the perspective of the object, meaning the conditions of peace themselves. The happy conditions for the life of the individual and society have not yet been created according to the standard of Truth that these peacemakers desire. Necessarily, there is and always will be a significant minority in society dissatisfied with these conditions, as we previously proved the weakness of Truth. This minority will always remain ready material for new warmongers and new peacemakers to cycle endlessly.

The Peace of the Entire World Depends on the Peace of the Individual

Do not be surprised that I am mixing together the peace of a single society with the peace of the entire world. In truth, we have already reached such a level that the whole world is considered merely one society and one collective. This means that because every individual in the world draws the essence of his life and his sustenance from all people of the entire world, he thereby becomes enslaved to serve and care for the well-being of the entire world.

We proved earlier the absolute subjugation of the individual to his society, akin to a small gear in a machine, which is because he draws his entire life and happiness from that society. Therefore, the benefit of the society and his private benefit are one and the same, and vice versa. Thus, to the extent that a person is bound to himself, he inevitably becomes bound to society, as we elaborated above.

One must understand with this that the scale of that "society" we spoke of is measured by the distance from which the individual draws his sustenance. For example, in ancient historical periods, this distance was measured only within one family. Meaning, the individual did not need anyone's help except his own family members. Then, he was certainly only subjugated to his own family members. In later periods, families joined into towns and districts, and the individual became subjugated to his town. Later, when towns and districts joined into nations, and the individual's life happiness was aided by all citizens of the state, he thereby became subjugated to the entire state. Therefore, in our generation, when every individual is aided in his life's happiness by all the countries of the world, it is inevitable that the individual becomes subjugated to the entire world to that same degree, like a gear within a machine.

Consequently, it is inconceivable to establish good and happy systems through peaceful means in one country while it is not so in all countries of the world, and vice versa. Because in our era, countries are linked to one another in supplying the necessities of life, just as individuals were in their families in ancient times. Therefore, we can no longer speak of or deal with just systems that guarantee peace for only one state or one nation, but only the peace of the entire world. For the benefit and harm of every single individual in the world is dependent and measured by the measure of the benefit of the individuals in the entire world.

Even though this matter is already quite known and felt in practice, nevertheless, the world has not yet properly grasped it in theory. This is due to the natural course of evolution, where the action precedes the understanding of matters, and only actions will prove and push humanity forward.

Truth and Mercy, Justice and Peace, Contradict Each Other

As if the aforementioned concrete, practical difficulties hindering our path were not enough for us helpless beings, a great confusion and war is added due to our psychological inclinations. That is, because of the attributes themselves that rule over each of us uniquely, contrasting from one person to another. Since the four mentioned attributes—Mercy, Truth, Justice, and Peace—which are distributed in human nature whether through evolution or education, contradict one another.

When we take, for example, the attribute of Mercy in its abstract form, we find that its ruling power contradicts all other attributes; meaning, under the laws of the rule of Mercy, there is no longer any room for the appearance of the other attributes in our world. For the attribute of Mercy is interpreted and defined by the saying, "Mine is yours, and yours is yours," as the Sages said in the Mishnah (Avot 5:10). If the entire world behaved according to this attribute, all the glory and preciousness of the attribute of Truth and Judgment would be abolished. When every one of us is naturally ready to give all he has to others, and not take anything from others, the entire concept and motivation to lie to one's fellow is abolished, and there is no room to speak of the attribute of Truth at all. For truth and falsehood are relative to each other; if there were no falsehood in the world, we would have no concept of truth. Needless to say, the other attributes, which sprouted and came only from the weakness of Truth to strengthen it, as mentioned above.

And Truth, defined by the saying "Mine is mine, and yours is yours," contradicts the attribute of Mercy and cannot tolerate it at all. According to Truth, it is not proper to toil and exert oneself for another, because besides stumbling one's friend and habituati

...