ASHLAG ARCHIVE
EnglishעבריתРусскийEspañol

Letter 39: The Prohibition of Cursing Any Person of Israel

Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein

Supplied text and translations. Original source files are available below; French translations are retained in the original downloads.

Source files
Text size

Letters — Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein

Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Letters

Letter 39: The Prohibition of Cursing Any Person of Israel

Regarding your question on the interpretation of the Oath "That they shall not ascend by a wall" (Shelo Ya'alu B'Choma)[1], I will explain it to you, God willing, immediately after the Passover holiday.

Regarding the people who curse:

It is said (Isaiah 49:17): "Your destroyers and they that made you waste shall go forth from you," Heaven forefend.

It is not even worth my while right now to think about them, for the Truth will show its way.

The Baal Davar (Evil Inclination/Satan) has ways to approach every single person in different manners.

...Do not speak with them and do not associate with them. All this stems from the fact that they do not wish to see their own blemish, and therefore they search for sins in others.

If they were to study the Hidden Torah (Torat HaNistar), the Torah would refine and purify the person to look at himself and contemplate why he lives and for what purpose the Holy One, Blessed be He, created him; then he would have no room to see evil in another.

We can bless and say: "Blessed is our God who created us for His glory and separated us from these who go astray," who are further from repentance than sinners, Heaven forefend.

For a sinner who knows he has sinned, when some awakening comes to him, he confesses, abandons [the sin], and receives mercy. But these people are righteous in their own eyes, may God save us.

A Homily regarding Slander:

I will write to you what I said in the name of a certain great man, to one who spoke evil of a fellow man to him.

When he asked him, "Why do you need to slander a Jew?", the man answered: "It is a Mitzvah to bury him, for he is a sinner of Israel."

He replied to him:

"There is proof from the Torah that it is NOT a Mitzvah to bury a man of Israel [i.e., to attack/condemn him].

For at the Exodus from Egypt, it is written (Ezekiel 16:22): 'And you were naked and bare,' and the Sages said[2]: 'Naked of Mitzvot.'

Yet it is written (Rashi, Exodus 10:22) that during the Three Days of Darkness, many wicked of Israel died who did not want to leave Egypt, and the darkness was so the Egyptians would not see them burying the wicked of Israel.

Now, if you say that it IS a Mitzvah to bury a wicked person of Israel, how could the verse say 'And you were naked and bare'—that the Children of Israel were naked of Mitzvot? After all, during the three days of darkness, they buried many wicked people!

Rather, it implies from here that there is no Mitzvah to bury a man of Israel in any way."

I conclude and say Shalom. Celebrate the Festival of Freedom with gladness and joy, and may we speedily merit to go from darkness to Great Light.

Yehuda Tzvi

[1] Ketubot 111a: "Why these three oaths? One, that Israel shall not ascend by a wall [force the redemption/mass immigration]..."

[2] Mechilta Bo 5: "Naked of all Mitzvot."