Articles & study materials — Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein
Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein / Festivals
Purim
The Mishnah teaches (Megillah 2a): "The Megillah is read on the 11th, 12th, 13th, 14th, and 15th [of Adar], no less and no more." The phrase "no less and no more" is puzzling; it should have said "not earlier and not later."
According to the inner meaning (Pnimiyut), we understand this simply. The Sages were precise.
"Esther" is the name of Malkhut (Kingship/Shechinah) when she is in concealment (Hester), as the Sages said: "I will surely hide (Haster Astir) My face" (Deut. 31:18)[1].
"Megillat Esther" (Scroll of Esther) means Malkhut when she shines with Revealed Lights (Gillum) that uncover the concealments.
The Holy Shechinah is the secret of the Moon, which has no light of its own, only what Zeir Anpin (the Sun) gives her.
Zeir Anpin illuminates the Nukva (Malkhut) via three lines (Right, Middle, Left). Each line has ten Sefirot, corresponding to the thirty days of the lunar month:
Days 1-10: Right Line (Chesed/Abraham).
Days 11-20: Middle Line (Tiferet/Jacob).
Days 21-30: Left Line (Gevurah/Isaac).
The cycle of the moon is as follows: Since Malkhut also provides sustenance for the external forces (Klipot)—as written "And His kingdom rules over all" (Psalms 103:19)—when she begins to shine (New Moon), the external forces come to suckle from her. When she reaches the 15th day (Full Moon), she possesses the entire Right Line and the right half of the Middle Line, and she is in her fullness. She then fears that the external forces might rob her abundance and take more than necessary for their existence. Therefore, she stops the coupling (Zivug) and begins to diminish until the end of the month. When the external forces see she has nothing to give, they leave her[2]. Then the coupling renews for the next month. This will continue until the End of Correction, when "night will shine like day."
Now the Mishnah is understood: "The Megillah is read..."—meaning, when can the Megillah of Esther be revealed to all eyes ("Eye to eye they shall see")?
"Only on the 11th"—meaning, when Malkhut (Esther) has the entire Right Line (10 days) plus the Keter of the Middle Line (1 day), totaling 11 Lights. The Right alone (10) are hidden lights, so the Megillah cannot be read with less than 11.
And "Not more than the 15th"—because beyond that (when the Left becomes too dominant or when she diminishes), there is a fear that external forces will take the abundance.
In Tikunei Zohar (Tikun 21), it is explained that Yom Kippurim (Day of Atonement) means Ke-Purim (Like Purim). Purim shines with the lights of the Final Correction—Repentance from Love, where sins become merits.
This is the secret of: "One is obligated to become intoxicated (Livsumei) on Purim until he does not know the difference between 'Cursed is Haman' (all sins) and 'Blessed is Mordechai' (all merits)." This comes from sweetening the judgments at their root, where everything turns to good[3], in the secret of "And it was turned to the contrary" (Esther 9:1).
Alternatively, it can be said:
Why is Yom Kippur called "Yom Ke-Purim" (A day like Purim)[4]?
Purim is the miracle of erasing Amalek. Yom Kippur is the light of forgiveness. Both have the effect of erasing the memory of Amalek.
However, why is Yom Kippur a day of Judgment (fasting), while Purim is a mitzvah to be Joyful and drink?
The explanation requires depth. Purim days are days of joy because of the erasure of Amalek, who cast doubts (Sfeikot) on faith in God. Amalek (Amalek - 240) has the same gematria as Safek (Doubt). The snake said "Has God said?" (Ha-Af) casting doubt[5].
It is written: "There is no joy like the resolution of doubts." Therefore, we rejoice on Purim because doubts were resolved.
On Purim, "They confirmed and accepted" (Esther 9:27)—"They confirmed out of love what they had accepted [at Sinai] out of coercion" (Shabbat 88a).
On Yom Kippur, we merit lights of forgiveness through five afflictions (fasting) and are sealed for Life (revelation of Wisdom/Chaya). However, this light of Wisdom cannot shine without Chassadim (Mercy). The time for drawing Chassadim is the seven days of Sukkot. Only on Hoshana Rabbah is the clothing of Wisdom in Chassadim completed, and the seal of Yom Kippur is finalized.
Therefore, on Purim, the miracle was the revelation of Wisdom clothed in Chassadim on the very same day, as written: "And Mordechai went out... with a great golden crown." Gold = Wisdom[7]; Greatness = Chesed. This completeness brings immediate joy. But on Yom Kippur, the process is not finished until Sukkot.
Alternatively, it can be said:
The Zohar says on "Let the power (Koach) of the Lord be great" (Num 14:17): Koach (28) hints at two times 14 (Yad).
First 14 (Yad): The secret of Purim (14th of Adar), starting with erasing Amalek.
Second 14 (Yad): Completed on the 14th of Nisan (Passover eve), "On the light of the 14th we search for leaven," removing the "leaven" (death/evil inclination) until death is swallowed forever.Then, the light of the second Yad is revealed: "For a hand (Yad) is upon the throne of Yah" (Exodus 17:16), leading to the great Mochin of the Exodus.
Currently, God's Name and Throne are incomplete because of Amalek (lacking Vav-He and Aleph). In the future redemption, "God has chosen Zion... Ivah (desired) for His dwelling." The letters of Ivah (Aleph, Vav, He) complete the Name and the Throne[9].
[1] Chullin 139b.
[2] See TES Part 9, 77.
[3] Explained in Birkat Shalom.
[4] Zohar: Purim is named after Yom Kippurim... future pleasure changes affliction to delight.
[5] Bnei Yissaschar: "Hishi'ani" contains letters of Yesh-Ayin (Existence-Nothingness/Doubt).
[7] Zohar Terumah 157: Gold is the illumination of the Left (Wisdom).