Writings of Baal HaSulam / Letters / Letter 18
From the 20th of Shevat 5685 (1925) — To R. Moshe Baruch Lamberger
With the help of God, Friday, Erev Shabbat Kodesh Mishpatim, 20th of Shevat 5685, Warsaw, may it be preserved.
To my soul's friend, the honorable M. Moshe Baruch, n.y., for eternity:
After inquiring after his good welfare.
Yesterday I received your letter, and I enjoyed it, for I see that at least you wish to fulfill my will. Regarding your first question, your words are very stammering, and it is a very deep matter. I am busy now, but nevertheless I will elaborate a bit on the matter, perhaps you will understand and accept it from now on.
I already said in the name of the Baal Shem Tov, that before performing a mitzvah, one should not think at all about particular providence (hashgacha pratit), but rather, on the contrary, a person must say: "If I am not for myself, who is for me?" (Avot 1:3). But after the action, a person is obligated to settle down and believe that not through his own strength and the might of his hand did he perform the mitzvah, but solely through the strength of God, for thus He thought concerning him from the very beginning, and thus he was compelled to act.
Likewise is the order in worldly matters (miley d'alma), for spirituality and corporeality are balanced. Therefore, before a person goes out to the marketplace to earn a living day by day, he must remove his thoughts from particular providence, and say then: "If I am not for myself, who is for me?", and perform all the reality that physical people do, so that he may earn his money like them. However, in the evening, when he comes to his house and his wage is with him, heaven forbid that he should think that his numerous maneuvers made him the profit; rather, even if he had been lying in the cellar all day long, his wage would likewise have been found in his hand, for thus the Almighty thought concerning him from the very beginning, and thus it had to be.
Even though to external intellect these are contradictory matters and are not accepted by the heart, nevertheless a person is obligated to believe thus, for thus the Almighty engraved for us in His Torah, from the mouths of scribes and from the mouths of books.
This is the secret of the unification of "Havayah Elokim." For the secret of Havayah is the secret of particular providence, that the Almighty enlivens everything, and does not need the dwellers of houses of clay to help them. And Elokim in gematria is Teva (Nature)—that a person who conducts himself according to nature, which He engraved in the systems of physical heaven and earth, and keeps their laws like the rest of physical things; and along with this finds himself believing in the Name Havayah, meaning in particular providence—he thereby unifies this with that, and they become one in his hand, and through this he brings great gratification to his Maker, and brings illumination to all the worlds.
This is the secret of the three aspects: mitzvah, aveirah (transgression), reshut (permission/neutral). For mitzvah is the place of holiness. Aveirah is the place of the Sitra Achra. And reshut, which is neither mitzvah nor aveirah, is the place of the battlefield upon which holiness and the Sitra Achra fight. When a person does neutral (reshut) things and does not unify them to the domain of holiness, then this entire place falls to the domain of the Sitra Achra; and when a person strives to perform unifications in neutral matters according to his strength, he returns reshut to the boundary of holiness.
Through this I explained what our Sages said: "From here [we learn] that permission (reshut) is granted to a physician to heal." Meaning, even though healing is in the hands of God without a doubt, and human stratagems will not move Him from His place, nevertheless the holy Torah informed us: "And he shall surely heal (verapo yerape)," to inform you that it is reshut, which is the place of the battlefield between mitzvah and aveirah as mentioned above. If so, we are obligated on our own part to conquer this reshut under holiness. And how is it conquered? Namely, when a person goes to a skilled physician, and the physician gives him a tried and tested medicine proven a thousand times, and after he merits to receive the healing and is well, then he is obligated to believe that without the physician the Almighty would likewise have healed him, for his life is already measured out from the very beginning. Instead of singing and praising the human physician, he gives thanks and praises to the Almighty, and thereby conquers reshut under the boundary of holiness. Along this line is the matter with other "neutral" (reshut) things.
Through this he goes and broadens the borders of holiness, in the manner that holiness broadens in all its measure, and suddenly he sees himself and his entire stature standing and living in the holy palace, for holiness and its borders have broadened so much that they reached his very own place. Understand this.
All this I explained to you in your place several times; because this matter is a stumbling block to many people who lack a clarified acceptance of particular providence, and "a servant prefers license" (Gittin 13a), and in the place of labor he prefers to trust [in nature]; and even more so he craves to cancel the difficulties from his faith, and to acquire for himself signs and wonders above nature—therefore they are punished and their blood is upon their heads. For from the sin of Adam HaRishon onward, God invented a rectification for this sin in the secret of the unification of Havayah Elokim in the manner I explained, which is the secret of "In the sweat of thy brow shalt thou eat bread" (Genesis 3:19). It is human nature that what one attains specifically through the abundance of his efforts, it is very difficult for him to say that it is a gift from the Almighty; consequently, he has a place of labor to exert himself in complete faith in particular providence and decide that even without his labor he would have attained all this, and through this this iniquity goes and is sweetened.
Therefore, after you knew and wrote that nature is a condition from the Almighty as mentioned above, how could you doubt again to occasionally transgress, God forbid, the condition of "And it shall come to pass" (ve-haya) for whatever may happen, transgressing the condition of the Almighty which certainly will not succeed without a doubt, for he does not unify the Name of Havayah Elokim, and "one who says 'I will sin and repent, [and sin again]', they do not grant him the opportunity to repent" (Yoma 85b)? Furthermore, why does he need imaginary trials when there are actual practical actions? Nor do I understand how it could enter one's mind to think that one need not determine particular providence, when I have already warned about this many times.
And what was written regarding judgment—to grieve over the fleshly draw—this is certainly a mandatory obligation, and if you are a man of valor, you have no action throughout the entire day and always where you will not find upon examination some stains—meaning that you too helped in the slightest to the completion of this action, and all the more so at a time of anger, and likewise at a time of jealousy, and in the feeling of arrogance and the like, which are all stains coming from the webs of thoughts that "my strength and the might of my hand have gotten me this wealth."
However, great skill is required not to fall on account of this into negligence in service, for one cannot arouse the good inclination against the evil inclination and say "If I am not for myself, who is for me?" and the like, as is written (Proverbs 14:16): "A fool rageth, and is confident," but rather as I wrote in the name of the Baal Shem Tov above. All the aforementioned are fixed laws that shall not be canceled, heaven forbid, and they are eternal.
One must understand in this that "My thoughts are not your thoughts" (Isaiah 55:8), and regarding the Almighty there is no concept of contrariness in reality at all, and all this is an evaluation relative to our five senses. One must understand that all the letters and combinations originate from our side, and from the mouth of the Most High everything is included in two forms—namely, the aspect of niyacha (rest) and the aspect of rogza (wrath/motion) which surround all the occurrences of the world, for niyacha includes rest and all its delights, while rogza includes the power of motion and all wrath... and all motions... the novelty of creation, which is the secret of "I form the light, and create darkness" (Isaiah 45:7)... ...... ...