The Rebbe of the Histadrut Naftali Lavie · Haaretz · 20 September 1957 · p. 3 English translation from Hebrew The General Federation of Labour, the Histadrut, has sought to demonstrate its liberal attitude toward its religious members by establishing a religious affairs office and a Religious Worker faction. Yet this has not dispelled the impression among the religious public that the Histadrut represents the anti-religious element in the country. With more than half a million members, some 100,000 of them religious, it could no longer remain indifferent to the religious question. Its two religious bodies could not meet the demands of tens of thousands of religious members among the new immigrants: neither could rival the religious parties in their influence among believers. Hence the need for a department within the Histadrut to provide religious services. Four well-known rabbis, several prominent religious party activists and one religious workers’ party negotiated with Executive Committee representatives on this basis. Three rabbis hold senior positions in HaPoel HaMizrachi, and one of them serves in the army. All three are active party men, and for that very reason the talks came to nothing. The fourth never held a rabbinical post, though he had been ordained by three outstanding Torah scholars of the preceding generation: Chief Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook, Rabbi Hayyim Yosef Sonnenfeld, chief rabbi of the Edah HaHaredit, and Rabbi Yaakov Moshe Harlap, of blessed memory. He earned his living doing building work in the streets of Jerusalem and taught the esoteric tradition to his pupils in his spare time. It was this strictly observant man, who had never been involved in the country's public affairs, whom the Executive Committee representatives chose to head the department. Talks with Poalei Agudat Israel fail The Histadrut emissaries’ approaches to HaPoel HaMizrachi leaders went no further. One of the men approached expressed willingness to accept the post on the terms under which the department has now been established. But the Histadrut representatives were not enthusiastic about this candidate, whose standing among religious people was uncertain. They were interested, however, in negotiating with Rabbi K. F. Tchorz, a member of the Chief Rabbinate in Tel Aviv and head of the HaPoel HaMizrachi rabbinical association. Talks were still at an early stage when the Executive Committee representative discovered “right-wing tendencies” in the candidate; negotiations ended before they had formally begun. Very serious talks were held with Poalei Agudat Israel (PAI). Histadrut secretary Pinhas Lavon, Mapai secretary Dr. Giora Josephthal, Knesset member Yona Kese and other Histadrut and Mapai figures found common ground with PAI leaders, who were willing to take responsibility for the Federation's religious affairs. The agreement was conditional on PAI joining the General Federation. PAI leaders, who did not see themselves as competitors of the Histadrut or the ruling party, were prepared to work with their sister workers’ party within the Federation, provided the religious interests of individuals and of the community were safeguarded. The Histadrut negotiators also wanted an agreement: the entry of this workers’ party might strengthen Mapai’s majority. That gave the negotiators, all members of the majority party, a considerable interest in the proposed agreement. Pressure from leading Torah scholars on PAI leaders prevented it, however, and the Histadrut representatives concluded that further talks would serve no purpose. Talks between HaPoel HaMizrachi and the Religious Worker There is still no proof of which came first: did the Histadrut's approaches to HaPoel HaMizrachi prompt that movement to make contact with the Religious Worker, or was it the other way around? What is certain is that while Federation emissaries were talking to HaPoel HaMizrachi, National Religious Party leaders invited the Religious Worker faction to join their party. The talks lasted nearly six months. At one meeting of the Religious Worker secretariat, a HaPoel HaMizrachi representative proposed that its members join the National Religious Party as a group, with suitable representation in all party bodies. The Religious Worker's resentment at the Executive Committee for negotiating with other religious groups evidently drew it closer to HaPoel HaMizrachi, and agreement was quite near. HaPoel HaMizrachi activists did not expect a large increase in membership. Their aim was mainly demonstrative: an agreement would have given them a useful weapon against the Histadrut in the immigrant settlements as elections drew near. The prospect appears to have hastened the Histadrut's preparations to establish the religious services department. During discussions of the 1957/58 budget the Executive Committee had voted in principle to allocate 100,000 Israeli pounds for the new department. This enabled its representatives to negotiate and conclude an agreement. Without involving the other factions represented on the Central Committee or consulting the Religious Worker faction, Mapai’s Executive Committee representatives approached a Torah scholar who had only just emerged from obscurity. After lengthy inquiries the candidate, the Stratyn Rebbe, Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein, agreed to head the department without any salary. Religious Worker leaders promptly refused to participate on a non-party basis. Only after several meetings was a three-person leadership agreed upon: Rabbi Brandwein, the department head; A. Ehrlich for the Religious Worker; and S. Levi for the religious affairs office of the cultural department. The other factions do not object We asked representatives of the Histadrut’s minority factions where they stood. They had no objection to the establishment or composition of the department. Mapam representative B. Lin believes increased Histadrut activity in religious affairs will loosen new immigrants’ ties to the religious parties and lessen those parties’ influence. Representatives of Ahdut HaAvoda–Poalei Zion and the Zionist Worker agreed. The latter faction’s representative, Y. Shaari, stressed that the department’s work might indeed serve a particular party in its competition with HaPoel HaMizrachi, which works in these areas through the Ministry of Religious Affairs. The speakers were more reserved about the choice of the Rebbe himself. Some felt that a rebbe who represented the old Jewish community to a certain extent might be better suited to the post than a different kind of religious figure. Poalei Agudat Israel, still outside the Federation, responded with restraint. “If it turns out that the Histadrut truly wishes to provide for the religious needs of its members, all the better,” its leaders say, adding that the strictly observant public would welcome this. Well-known rabbis in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv, including some noted for their uncompromising views, responded similarly. HaPoel HaMizrachi leaders, by contrast, maintain that the Histadrut hopes to gain a political advantage by setting up the department under a rebbe. The Rebbe promises “religion for its own sake” For the first time in his life the Rebbe appeared this week before a different kind of “Hasidim”: the Histadrut Central Committee, veteran labour activists and members of the new department. The little-known rebbe, who to this day spends most of his time over his books, found himself in the Executive Committee building, surrounded by religious colleagues and secular sons of rabbis, Histadrut leaders who had brought him to this post. No programme has yet been presented, but one promise was made: “Religion for its own sake, not religion for the sake of a party or a party for the sake of religion.” How does he propose to achieve this? “Quite simply, through love of the Jewish people and without any coercion.” We asked about the budget. The department has been promised 180,000 pounds. He wishes to tour the country, the immigrant settlements, veteran workers’ neighbourhoods and kibbutzim, to talk to people and hear about their spiritual needs. Requests have already come in for 250 synagogues and about a hundred Torah classes. We were unable to establish the Rebbe’s own outlook. He is 54, of the house of Stratyn, and was born in Safed. His modest apartment on the edge of Tel Aviv's Yemenite Quarter, his manners, his origins in the unassuming court of Stratyn and his working background all suggest that he belongs to the “working class.” On his return from a Hungarian yeshiva he took no sacred office. Instead he climbed the scaffolding of buildings he erected in Jerusalem’s Bukharan Quarter. Manual labour did not keep him from devotion to both esoteric and revealed Torah. Jerusalem’s leading rabbis ordained him, and the Stratyn Hasidim “crowned” him their rebbe. Since the end of the Second World War he has lived in Tel Aviv and barely made ends meet. Yet in agreeing to head the Histadrut department he stipulated expressly that he would take no salary. His second condition was that the Federation should fulfil its promises to the department in good faith. We asked what rabbis and rebbes thought of the Histadrut’s new rebbe, whose realm stretches over half a million “Hasidim.” Most answered both yes and no. Interestingly, someone close to Neturei Karta welcomed the appointment, expressing hope that it might mark a change for the better in the Federation’s handling of religious matters. The Rebbe himself is not disconcerted by the campaign of vilification that certain religious circles have begun against him. Photograph caption Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Brandwein